Nick's New Haven Style Pizzeria and Bar

Dined in and had the plain cheese with mushrooms and the Margherita. This score is for the plain cheese with mushrooms. On the positive side, the pizza tasted great sauce and cheese were good. It had char, but couldve been crispier especially being coal-fired. My deduction for it not being a mid-to-high seven was the flop was far too severe. I had to use two hands to eat the pizza - even after it wax cooled down.

Best New Haven style pizza I’ve had in South Florida. Reminds me of CT.

My pizza was Delivered cold so my review would be higher if it was warm . Please send drives with pizza in a pizza bag

Perfectly charred. Sauce is very tasty. The crust is soft on the inside & crunchy on the outside.

This is extremely good coal fired pizza. Must get for real, friendly and great martini too boot

Great flavor, little floppy but the crunch is on point. The vibe checks out.

Lota flop Good sauce. Got a lil better as it cooled. Chicken tenders for my kid were great.

Had the looks, super flop, too much cheese, tasty sauce. Don’t understand how the crust is thin and with a good char but no crisp and was straight out of the oven.

I agree with Dave. Great char and taste!

Always delicious Perfect crust, tasty sauce... Dave might be in Cooooohooots with OVER-RATED AH beets = Over-rated

Wasn't as crispy as it looks. Had a different taste to it. Was still a decent pie.

Very good pizza

Was a Damn good pie, heavy oregano tasting. Cesar Salad was excellent.

Not bad pretty good

Lil flop. Grease. Great taste. Could use more crisp.

Outstanding New Haven Style, love Dave P but he underscored this incredible pie

Delicious. Worth the visit.

Great flavor , crust is very tasty , but wayyy too much flop.

This Pizza slaps…🔥🔥🔥

Solid representation of NH style. I had less flop than Dave.