Nick's Pizza & Ice Cream

The size of the slice was impressive, but that's where the praise ends. If only the sauce wasn't so nonexistent...

I know the best pizza is New Haven CT and NYC but living in Valhalla NY this is the best pizza within 10 miles.

Good quality big slice. Perfect after a long day of work. It is a little prices but look at the zip code. 🤷🏻‍♂️

1 cheese slice and 1 chicken parm slice, 1:30pm on a Friday, $9.18 Pros: Well browned undercarriage, decent bubbling, lot of crunch in the crust, a couple coastline bites had some decent sauce hits Cons: Oversized slice pizza flavor, $9 for 2 slices, one being plan cheese, hurts. Maybe I was accidentally overcharged - or this is very overpriced pizza. Chicken slice was pretty dried out, usually a result of dicing chicken too finely Verdict: Portnoy talks about giant slices usually not being very good and these aren't mega slices but they're big and taste like it. I'm kind of upset about paying $9.

Very Good slices and variety. Zero flop and not greasy at all

Doughy floppy weird tasting. Did I say doughy. No crunch. Big slices.

Solid slice here. Sauce has a nice tang, not too greasy. A little floppy though.

Classic Italian move with the pizza and pasta mix. Fair score, pasta may be better then the pizza. No flop as well. Would have it again

No flop on a “two-plate” slice and the crust had a good crunch. Cheese was good, little greasy, but easy to chew and had some good taste. Sauce was pretty darn good and I enjoyed the taste a lot. Definitely recommend. Try the ice cream as well!! Nice workers and quick service.

Eh

Humongous as you can see. Very greasy, cheese and crust were pretty burned. Still almost average because of solid ingredients.