Nick's Slice Of Brooklyn Pizzeria & Bar

Good sauce and cheese flavor... Little too much flop for me... Probably still the best pizza I found in PCB

This place is a disgrace to pizza, and it’s name “slice of Brooklyn” any new yorker would take one good look at that pizza and tell you that your out of your damn mind. The pizza slid right off and was impossible to pick up. The meat is also gross and under cooked. Seems like a once good pizza place that has changed into lazy ways to speed service.

Great pizza, very cool environment. Great tasting cheese and red sauce

Its crap.

I’m from Brooklyn, and this place should change its name. At best the slice was a ‘fast food’ version of a NY pizza. I’d recommend Charly’s Pizza, only a few miles away.

Great taste good crunch

Honestly this is the best pizza ive ever had and ive had pizza in New York this is my favorite pizza of all time

Lots of flop, not a fan of the sauce seemed like a lot of Italian seasoning in it.

This pizza place was just a couple miles down the road from the hotel I was staying at in Florida. The area inside was clean and the people were kind and working hard. As for the pizza it was a very good, floppy Brooklyn style pizza. The sauce had a great taste to it. The cheese though!!! The cheese made the pizza and was some of the best cheese I’ve had on a pizza before. I wish it was crispier and the dough had more flavor. But a darn solid pizza if you ask me. I’ll be back if I go back to Panama City beach and you should go there too! Pepperoni has a good flavor too if that’s your thing and I’d recommend that too!

Good cheese, good sauce, lots of flop

Decent when hot, but nothing to drive further than 10 minutes for, garlic knots were great

Lots of flop and a lot greasier than I get in Indiana but, solid flavor. The cheese was great, the sauce was fantastic, the crust was crispy.

Nice Brooklyn flop. Crust is on point and the cheese is perfect. The sauce is great but not a 9 great.

Homemade sauce... Tangy. Big chunks tomatoes. Not Dave's type but glad I tried it once. Pizza by the slice. I give it 6.1 fair score

Somewhat floppy but great taste. Would be better if it was left in the over a few more minutes.

Cheese, a little greasy but a local favorite

The dough makes it. Sauce and cheese are fine, nothing crazy. Solid, solid, pizza. A little greasy, but just a solid NY slice for PCB.

Very good pie

Strong 8/10. Pretty greasy. Could use a bit more sauce but overall good flavor. Also cashier was a total dick

Ordered well-done like everyone recommended and it was terrific. The crust was nice and crunchy, and it had just the right amount of flop