Nicky’s Firehouse Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Your standard NJ suburban pizza. Good cheese-sauce-bread ratio. Tangy sauce. Medium flop.

Really good pizza. The owner was cool. He told me to come back again. I did.

Good flop, great flavor!

Minimal flop. Thin slice. Crunchy. Light slice. Tasty.

Actually very positively surprised. Tasty and yummy tomato sauce. May be best in Madison

This pizza is fucking awesome best pizza in nj by far Nicky’s classic Italian firehouse motherfucking pizza. Come and get it niggas

Not my photo. Forgot to take one but solid slice.

Thin crust, nice cheese. Needs more flavor overall. Nothing special.

A little bit of flop. crust below average.