Firehouse Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

A “tavern” pie which is not as thin as a bar pie but on the thin side with oil and snappy crust. Reminds me of Squan Tavern or the Gateway. A cozy spot in the good town of Madison.

Great tasting pizza, they get all the ingredients right. Right amount of cheese, right amount of sauce. Not doughy.

Rating the plain slice only - The highlight with the slice is how thin it is. I feel like this just edges over the 6.9 mark. Not too much flavor with the cheese or sauce. Good pizza either way 🍕

This is no longer the Nicky’s we knew and loved. I’ve been going to Nicky’s since they first opened and continued to support them after new owners took over couple years ago. New owners are now using cheap ingredients, cheese is terrible and their new dough is wonder bread crust loaded with crap. We went from ordering a few times a week to a couple times a month but today was our last visit. They’ve been switching up pizza recipes using cheaper ingredients every visit more disappointing than the last. We had a good run but time for new pizza spot!

The standard in the area. Thin, crispy, and sauce that’s about as good as it gets

Really good slice of pizza. Every part of this slice was satisfying and my expectations were exceeded. Definitely will have again when I’m in the area!

Good flop

Great family restaurant with a solid sweet sauced pie. Baby approved!

We don’t get pizza like this in Vegas. Great sauce, crust is on another level. Nicely done.

Best pizza by far in New Jersey!!!!!!

Your standard NJ suburban pizza. Good cheese-sauce-bread ratio. Tangy sauce. Medium flop.

Really good pizza. The owner was cool. He told me to come back again. I did.

Good flop, great flavor!

Minimal flop. Thin slice. Crunchy. Light slice. Tasty.

Actually very positively surprised. Tasty and yummy tomato sauce. May be best in Madison

Not my photo. Forgot to take one but solid slice.

Thin, no flop. Sauce is tangy. I enjoyed the cheese too.

Thin crust, nice cheese. Needs more flavor overall. Nothing special.

A little bit of flop. crust below average.