Nicky's Pizzeria

For both Sicilian and NY Style. Yet to try the Grandma. Sicilian has great crunch and sauce/cheese ratio. The NY has great under carriage and no flop. Could use a little more sauce.

really good solid slices. Great structural integrity for the NY slice and good crisp. Sicilian Slice really good too also another 7.8 for both

Very good pizza, nice crisp undercarriage and excellent crust. Good size on the large pizza compared to others around town, and very affordable. Could use a bit more sauce, but overall a solid choice when you are in Lexington. Also excellent service from our server Ryan!

Picture (when you see oregano available without asking you dealing with a place that knows). While I do not agree it's a 8+ like many here is is a good standard pie. Cooked on stone. Tangy sauce. Cheese is not chewy and proportional to the other components. Flavors balance and crust flavor is on point with a little chew but toooooooo thick. Stretch it guys and it be a 7.3

Meat Lovers was best pizza I’ve had here. Good crisp,great sauce . Perfectly designed pizza .

Crust was great! Pizza was a little salty and too greasy for my taste.

Good crust, super super greasy

The BBQ chicken is amazing. This place is so much better than pappa gios! Wish they delivered!

Best pizza in Lexington and Columbia but not close to northeast US.

She loved the pizza

Cold cheese slice is phenomenal!

Good crust, little flop. LOTS of grease

Actually ended up giving it a third score in my video higher than 7.2 because it liked it more with each bite. Very good pizza!

Nickys likely has the best slice in the Columbia area. Their slices are always fresh, you never get a slice that looks like it's been sitting too long, it's always hot, the staff is always nice, and at $3.00 for a cheese slice, it is a great deal.

Good crunch. Nice sauce. A little too much cheese for my taste but a very good football pizza.

For Lexington this is very good pizza. Much needed in this area.

Very good