Nicola Pizza

Slightly bland but very good sauce

Started off as a 6.9 but after discussing our new score would have to be a 6.4

Started off pretty good but we had to bring the 6.9/7.0 down to a 6.6. The cheese really just did not meet our standards.

Sweet sauce, good crust. Little floppy and greasy cheese. Boil is better for sure

Sloppy but good

rubbery taste greasy bite bland doughy crust

Taste like childhood. If you’re a local, you know. If not, shut the fuck up and move on.

Very saucy and greasy. cheese could be a little tastier and tasty crust. Unique flavored sauce. Very hearty.

Little crunch on the crust, but a bit of an odd after-taste. Cheese stands out with a little caramelization, but the sauce is a bit bland in my opinion. I wouldn't avoid the place but I wouldn't seek out their regular cheese pizza, either. My sister gave it a 4.6, I went 5.3.

I would rather eat a Totinos frozen pizza. Not very good. Not a fan of the Nic-o-Boli either. I’d give that a 3.2

Just like the others, a frozen crust vibe hits you as immediately as a black ice air freshener. The crunch increased the score, but it’s just run of the mill beach pizza.

Beach pizza, greasy and cheesey.

Voted #1. Maybe #100 by my standards, sloppy mess