Top Restaurants

Nicolo's Restaurant

Nicolo's Restaurant

12459 Olean Road, Chaffee, New York

Pizza Review

2 likes

716pieguy on One Bite Pizza App

716pieguy

3 hours ago

Ho Ho Ho! Six Seven! As the crest hunts number 8 tonight, it sounds like the amount of divorces BuffaloPizzaGuy will go though. Because he has a face even a mother could NOT love. Anyways, the cheese was stellar but the sauce wasn’t existent. Dry Pie. When I got the sauce it was great but not enough of it.

Pizza Review

casualpizzaconnoisseur12/27/25, 11:20 p.m.

6.6

Well this place exceeded expectations, I was a little iffy trying this place.however I enjoyed this, good cheese, good pep solid slice. Can’t complain I call it how I see it, good stuff.

Pizza Review

bofapizza12/27/25, 11:12 p.m.

6.9

Tastes a lot better than it appears. Thought it would have the same taste as a lot of the shittier pizza spots, but this has a different tang to it. A bit dry but I can say I enjoy eating this. Needs a bit more to get into the 7s for me. I am sure I’ll find this pizza even more enjoyable after a couple jagerbombs tonight. Let’s get a slice night in soon fellas.

Pizza Review

716doctapizza12/27/25, 11:12 p.m.

6.8

Shockingly good pie. Had a good tangy flavor to the sauce which was a good surprise. Was a little greasy but not too thick not too thin. Really good cheese to sauce ratio. Good stuff