I know rookie score. But I was really surprised at the lower rating on this place. Really cool vibe inside, owners an old school Italian. Sauce is terrific, tasty cheese. It’s kind of a cross between ny style and bar pizza... they put the cheese on last.
one-bite-n-pa12/2/20, 1:31 a.m.
I haven't been here in ages. The outside has changed, but the inside is a time capsule back to the early 80s when we would stop here late night drunk and get a pie to go. Decent slices and the same employee as back in the day....
doug-abby-pizza-review8/2/20, 6:56 p.m.
Great crust, pretty greasy but overall a really nice cheese to sauce ratio. Sauce could’ve had some more flavor but it was still good. Crust was delicious, very crunchy. Service is great here too, asked for fresh slices and they right away offered to make a fresh pie
gary.ricker7/24/20, 9:50 p.m.
Crust a little doughy, sauce is sweet, little oil drip and minimal flop
scosang7/16/20, 7:44 p.m.
Just great pizza all around. Not a greasy as I remember so extra points for that.
pizza-q5/20/20, 1:14 a.m.
Excellent crunch on the crust (order it well done). Sauce has a great taste to it. Cheese is proportioned well so you have a good amount in every bite.
dapdrums4/30/20, 9:27 p.m.
The sauce puts it in the 8 range. Excellent pie. Very good service too (during the pandemic.)
anthony.chunglo3/7/20, 6:42 p.m.
Sicilian Pizza. Hard to compare to a traditional cheese slice, but decent. Good sauce flavor. Good crust.
keith.hornik3/1/20, 5:58 p.m.
Classic pie, local gold standard. When ever in phillipsburg, nj or easton, pa a must stop.
steven.roe1/22/20, 7:14 p.m.
Little Tangy needs a little more crisp to it good value for money
john.miller2112/19/19, 5:25 p.m.
Perfect sauce to cheese ratio and cash only and they only make pizza
katy12/1/19, 12:02 a.m.
Pizza was good, lots of sauce and crisp. Negative was we called 30 minutes ahead and still waited 20 minutes when we got there at a not busy time (5PM Saturday) cash only
kevin.price11/21/19, 1:03 a.m.
Nothing to see here just grease n shit but still ok sauce respectable and a bit crispy maybe had it been heated more than 30 seconds it would feel up a 7
james.sundheim11/5/19, 5:36 p.m.
I love this place and have even at times had some of the best pizza in my life from here. So why isnt it an 8 or a 9? Consistency. It's like Russian Roulette. Sometimes you get a great pie and sometimes you get a lake of grease sitting on top of some dough. When this place is on it's A-game you'll get a pie with a thick layer of sauce that borders on the sweet side, a nice thick layer of cheese that is DISTINCT from the sauce, not blended together, and a decent crust, though it could be crisper. If New York has the flop, Jersey has the curse when it comes to floppy crust. Oh well. If you go here you might be in great luck and have one of the best pies in your life, but it's not a sure bet.
wjstoney7/1/19, 8:42 p.m.
The taste was good this time compared to the Sicilian I got 2 months ago ,,I would give it a 7.5 if it was crispier,, it was too soft ,, but tasty
fyrfytr826/26/19, 12:35 p.m.
This a go to for me. Can be inconsistent depending on the pizzaiola. Best is sausage pie that has waited an hour. Just at room temp this pizza is a 9.2 !
mike.verdjak6/15/19, 6:54 p.m.
Crust is terrible, can’t taste the cheese over the grease but the sauce is top notch. .2 for nostalgia factor