Nicolosi's Pizza

7.7 is my overall score. The cheese slice was floppy and greasy but the flavor was great. Sauce was good and lots of cheese, 7.1. The Sicilian slice was delicious. Light, fluffy, crunchy, and flavorful 8.3

Definitely opt for the Sicilian here. They’re also known for their sausage but I didn’t try it. 7.6 on the Sicilian scale.

My highest score yet. Simply the best in/around the Lehigh Valley. A true classic pizzeria!

Average

A good football pie. Pretty good sauce nice amount of cheese a little bit of flop. Good slice

Overall good pizza. Really nice crisp crust. Hard place to find but a cool atmosphere inside.

Best around !

It's a good slice - no complaints. Sicilian was pretty good, too. Fair prices and hits the spot.

I haven't been here in ages. The outside has changed, but the inside is a time capsule back to the early 80s when we would stop here late night drunk and get a pie to go. Decent slices and the same employee as back in the day....

I know rookie score. But I was really surprised at the lower rating on this place. Really cool vibe inside, owners an old school Italian. Sauce is terrific, tasty cheese. It’s kind of a cross between ny style and bar pizza... they put the cheese on last.

Great crust, pretty greasy but overall a really nice cheese to sauce ratio. Sauce could’ve had some more flavor but it was still good. Crust was delicious, very crunchy. Service is great here too, asked for fresh slices and they right away offered to make a fresh pie

Crust a little doughy, sauce is sweet, little oil drip and minimal flop

Just great pizza all around. Not a greasy as I remember so extra points for that.

Excellent crunch on the crust (order it well done). Sauce has a great taste to it. Cheese is proportioned well so you have a good amount in every bite.

The sauce puts it in the 8 range. Excellent pie. Very good service too (during the pandemic.)

Crispy crust but lots of flop, cheese is on point! Solid pie

Sicilian Pizza. Hard to compare to a traditional cheese slice, but decent. Good sauce flavor. Good crust.

Classic pie, local gold standard. When ever in phillipsburg, nj or easton, pa a must stop.