Nico's Charred Pizza Pies

This pizza was very good. The crust was perfectly cooked and crispy. The basil on top added a nice touch. The only thing I would change is a little less sauce. Also try the cookies!!!

It is insanely crunchy, not a lot of sauce on pizza. Can hear the crunch another room, it’s that crunchy. Excellent pizza

This place is outstanding! As Dave Portnoy anointed it, “the best pizza on Long Island”. Clearly agree. Always high quality. Closest to The Havens we get. Crispy. And the Squares are even better than the rounds. And do not sleep on the Chocolate Chip Cookies either!

Delicious pizza. Very crispy and lives up to the charred name, sauce is very flavorful and sharp, and the cheese to sauce ratio is great. This is probably the best pizza I’ve ever had on Long Island.

Fantastic well deserved high score. Great crust, Ill be back. Get the cookie.

Charrrrrr

8.4 cheese, 8.1 pepperoni, only dissapointing fact was someone else took both of our pizzas (also ordered half white and half sausage) and by the time we asked where our food was, there was only 1 dough left. Chef/owner was stand up guy gave us money back and last dough on the house, just dissapointed in society and in people taking what they know isn’t theirs. Will be back to try the rest! Worth the 30 min drive and unintended 1 hr 15 min wait.

Probably in the top three best slices on Long Island.

Amazing crisp, great sauce, great spot.

Right up my alley. Crispy and thin. Will be back here. GPS will get you lost. Its basically under the train tracks on Railroad Ave. its a food truck inside Root & Branch

A hidden gem! Nico’s makes amazing pizza! Excellent flavors along with a crisp bottom and perfect undercarriage. They only sell pies. This place is a must! Dave has to come here.