robby.wander2/13/21, 7:13 p.m.
I’ve never given such a high score for a pizza. Maybe I feel compelled to today for other sentimental reasons. Or, maybe it’s because this reminds me of a Detroit style Pequods-esque crispy edge framed work of art. ❤️🍕🎨
ryan.meisemann11/1/20, 8:11 p.m.
Anyone that rated this higher than a 5 has clearly never had good pizza or is missing taste buds. I’d rather have papa John’s than this pie.
eric.bronstein7/21/20, 1:06 a.m.
Granted this is not my style of pizza, but this was an absolute disappointment. It is literally just bread and sauce. There was hardly any cheese on it and I even ordered extra cheese. This was beyond a letdown
dwypasek6/27/20, 4:09 p.m.
Ordered the Detroit Style Pizza, big fan of the soft pizza with the crunch of the crust and bottom
robert.hood6/26/20, 8:50 p.m.
Sauce was a little different but definitely not in a bad way. Crust was cooked almost perfectly, had a nice crisp to it. Very impressed
jeff.stackhouse6/18/20, 6:20 p.m.
A little greasy but I’m sure that’s mainly from the pepperoni. Very Good pizza! Would love to go back and try their other styles.
ashton.williamson2/11/20, 11:46 p.m.
Very good sauce and crunch! The cheese was a little weird. Needs higher quality cheese.
gspiz1/27/20, 11:01 p.m.
The Old Fashioned is the only pie that Prez would judge here. I did add basil. Sauce has great tang, not greasy, very crispy. Portnoy would give it a 7.9. Really good, but he wouldn’t go 8s.
benny.blanco1/16/20, 2:05 a.m.
Ordered the Super Margherita. The crust is thicker than most "fancy pizza" and the crust is crunchier too. Overall a REALLY good pizza!
christina.mommsen1/12/20, 7:32 p.m.
Although I got the tony pepperoni, my first two bites were sans pepperoni. The tomatoes are fresh, cheese is salty and gooey, crust is the right mix of crispy and chewy. Outstanding pizza.
erixmith1/12/20, 7:27 p.m.
Before someone calls me a rookie, I know it’s supposed to be a plain pizza...but my last review pointed out that N&R was more about the toppings. This tasting solidified that point in my mind. This is the one if the best pizza joints in the ATL and has the best atmosphere of any of them. Worth a visit if you’re ever in town. Great crust, great flavor, generous toppings.
aidensmitty2411/29/19, 9:51 p.m.
A little disappointed because I had high hopes for this. I was looking forward to the Detroit style, but they ran out. Anyway, their cheese pizza was not great. Very greasy, cheese and sauce was alright, but not great. It was crispy which was good. Overall, it was okay pizza but there are many better places in Atlanta.
mark.rapp10/20/19, 1:15 a.m.
A bit greasy and more doughy than I thought. Very good though. If it had more of a crisp I would elevate to higher than an 8
brandon.oot9/11/19, 4:23 p.m.
Forgot to take a picture because I couldn’t wait to dive into the pizza. So far one of the best places in Atlanta. Great cheese. Perfect flop.