Nina's Italian Resturant & Pizzera

In a college town type vicinity, surprisingly good. NYC style slice for sure. Try the “garbage” wings too. A nice stop on track to see the hall of fame. Honus Wagner or Lefty Gomez or Bob Feller would have pulled a Jason Biggs American Pie on these slices.

Upstate pizza just never seems to tickle my fancy

Solid great tasting slices

Good slice. Thin and crisp. Tasty sauce. Not too much cheese. The cheese left a little aftertaste that I found slightly off, but this was my favorite slice on the block.

Best Pizza in Oney

Drove from St. Louis, MO ✔️ Ordered New York style pizza ✔️Feel that the pizza was floppy, greasy and ordinary. ✔️

A good overall slice with a nice blend of crispy and doughy crust. A nice gooey cheese, the sauce doesn’t have much but it has enough flavor. Very greasy which hurt the score but no flop.

wouldn’t take my grandma out to lunch at nina’s

Davey Pageviews needs to get his ass up to O-town and experience the Nina’s cold cheese combo. No flop, excellent crisp, and the cold cheese elevates this into the 9’s. I challenge Portnoy to score this!!!