Alright so Johnny's is getting a 7.7 on the cheese slice and 7.9 on the "upside down" slice, (that's their name for it). Yuuuuge Slices OK, and the people behind the counter were awesome, very lively and interactive with all customers. I love the sauce on the upside down and the crust was crispy. I liked this slice a lot. Overall very cool place for a quick lunch.
Order now on Slice
Order Nina's Pizza
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
frank.simpson9/9/22, 1:14 a.m.
Stopped coming here awhile ago due to service, but the one bite review made me try again. 90 min wait for a slice, and I received a half cooked, limp, see through wet crust, with zero taste. They are a shit show still and rushing to fill all the orders, with the influx of new customers. The quality suffered hard, and was honestly one of the worst slices, I ha e ever had. Used to be solid.
worldwide.darts8/27/22, 3:21 a.m.
Pizza was decent. I thought it could've been a bit more crispy.
eric84227/31/22, 6:05 p.m.
The slices usually ok. Full pie undercooked, again. Better options around for NY style
austin.moore7/12/22, 7:19 p.m.
Classic ny style, big slices but just okay pizza. Gets the job done I guess
wexler4/2/22, 1:30 a.m.
I never had Johnny’s - however now that it’s Nina’s I don’t know if the quality changed. They told me everything is the same. The slice has a lot of potential!! However it’s clear that they used a dough ball from an XL pie (18” I think) for my Large 16” pie. This resulted in a very thick crust. Good flavor, nice sauce. Little too much grease and flop. 7.2 AS-IS but it could approach the 8’s IMO with some tweaks.
jim.wells112/31/21, 10:42 p.m.
No flop. Great flavor. If it was cooked for a bit longer it’d be in the 8’s. Definitely worth trying.
km01112/3/21, 12:50 a.m.
The interior at Johnny's actually reminded me of my hometown pizza place as a kid, with its slightly dated design and half a dozen or so large booths and the kitchen at the very end of the narrow floor plan. However, Johnny's Pizza was much better than the place I grew up on! LOL I went with my go-to 1-2 punch of a slice of cheese and a slice of buffalo chicken. Both slices were massive, and we're both very crispy with virtually no flop to be had! Their sauce had quite a bit of Tang and the cheese had some nice salty flavor. One of the better values I've seen as well, as I was able to get two slices and a drink for $5! The owner was also extremely nice, and her and I had quite a bit of small talk while I waited for my slices.
parker43911/5/21, 5:25 p.m.
Very good pizza, no flop, very good crunch, great sauce flavor. 8.2 this is a very good slice of pizza
skuzzey6/3/21, 4:55 p.m.
Little to no flop, great crust and crunch. Sauce leaves a pleasant after taste. Perfect amount of cheese
andy.steiner12/17/21, 11:25 p.m.
Got a fresh pie the other day and the family really liked it. Great crunch and no flop. Not a lot of tang to the sauce but a great everyday football pizza. Staff incredibly friendly as well. Highly recommend.
dwyerm027/3/20, 10:15 p.m.
Got delivery so it was medium warm. Good crust,football pizza,ok sauce.
28 views•1 like
roba11/6/19, 12:02 a.m.
Pepsi n Pizza! the sauce has a good tang, i wish the pizza was Crispier. For a small town pizza this is good. If the pizza was cooked a little longer to crisp the crust it would be easily a 7.1