Pizza Review
I usually don't like coal fired pizza but this is by far the best I've had. Good flavor, zero flop, and thin crust.

Order Nino's Coal Fired Pizza

Hungry? Order right now on Slice
Order now on Slice
Pizza Review
They cook their pies in an 1100° coal oven, a rare style for South Jersey & the Jersey Shore area. A very fancy looking pizza with some snazzy aesthetics, atypical of standard football pies that dominate this part of the Garden State. Despite a significantly charred undercarriage & crust, the dough doesn’t have any coal-oven crisp whatsoever; in fact, the texture is strikingly similar to a softer wood-fired consistency. However, the blackened bottom has a very tasty & smokey coal oven flavor. Fairly firm with mostly minimal flop, the dough isn’t flimsy despite the lack of true crisp. The crust is also on the softer side with just a hint of crunch, despite the deliciously charred taste. Supposedly just shredded mozzarella, the cheese has an odd, funky flavor & unusual consistency, not in a bad way, just different, leaning more towards a Margherita style. Maybe the imported olive oil atop the pie alters the taste of the cheese a touch; or perhaps some sprinkles of Parmesan distract from the mozzarella flavor just a bit. San Marzano tomatoes account for the sauce instead of a purée. They’re sweet, but not too sweet, lacking tang & zip. The crushed tomatoes are smattered atop the pie instead of mixed in a sauce blend underneath the cheese. Feels like it’s missing some oomph, in need of spices & seasoning; the tomatoes are too simple. Some slight confetti strips of basil add a splash of color but don’t provide much additional flavor. In summation, this is a nice attempt at a classier, fancier, coal-fired football pie; but the absence of crisp defeats the purpose of the coal oven, creating a glaring need for a crispier pizza. Overall, this pie is still pretty tasty but not spectacular; much better than average for South Jersey/Jersey Shore pizza though.
3 likes