Nino's Pizzeria

Nobody seems to impressed with this place but I really likes my slice!! Thin and crispy, great flavor. I wasn’t expecting it at all, the decor is pretty standard. Not someplace I would sit and eat.. but driving by and grabbing a slice.. It was very much to my liking.. the guy who made it looks like he’s been there a while.. based on reviews, I was thinking different pizza maker. I dunno… l liked it!!

Fresh but a little too much cheese. Also mindful that this was a drunk slice—stopped here after a trip to Fire island.

Is it going blow you away, no. Are you going to brag about it, no. Just stock standard LI/football slice. It’s decent enough to make this your local Friday pizza place.

Nino’s! One of the best Sicilian slices I’ve had on the Island. Sauce makes it! Ask for it well done.

Taste like the store bought frozen pizza. Not gonna go out of my way for this sort of thing

Big flop with a lot of grease. Not a terrible slice. Has a decent amount of cheese