Nonna Bella's Pizza Cafe

Okay pizza overall. I will say though it was thin and a little burnt. It wasn't horrible though.

Very solid slice. Thin and crispy

Regular: dough is thin not super crispy but still crispy. Cheese to sauce ratio is off a slightly. Some people may prefer more cheese. All and all it's a good slice. 7.9 Grandma vodka: dough is spot on, crispy bottom soft though out. Sauce is spot on. Very good slice 9.1 Grandma: dough is spot on just like the vodka slice. The tomatoes are slightly bland but still very good. 8.5

Solid football slice, order fresh pie, light, crisp, tangy, easily can crush a pie

wow the upside down grandma slice is amazing the girl behind the counter is a sweetheart

My review is based off the plain slice. Crust is thin which gives it a great crispy bite. Sauce has really good flavor and not too much how I like it. Cooked well and it wasn’t greasy. Definitely a very solid slice.

Nice sauce 👌

Nice Slice none of that North Babylon flop, the crust is nice and crispy sauce has some Tang. And that's the review

Chicken penne ala vodka slice

One bite everyone knows the rules.... It's time for a re-review! In my initial review I did THE PEOPLE a disservice by scoring this slice based on a reheat. I needed to score this while I was at the source. This is a SOLID local slice. Great football/family pizza. Decent flop even though the dough and crust are nice and thin. More importantly the dough and crust have a great flavor. Def uses a whole milk cheese and they don't skimp on it. The only thing keeping this pizza from hitting a solid 8 is the sauce. I get hit with a strong oregano flavor. If we could get an appropriate level of tang and sweetness this would be a home run.

Not dogshit

Rating 7.2

Unreal sauce

Cheese is meh, sauce is average. Not that crispy. Not a fan of the ‘popcorn’ crust.

Football pizza, Frankie. Good crunch with the planko crumbs on the bottom. Want it to be crispier tho. Pepperoni is meh, prefer the smaller cut and curled pepperoni.

Good pizza. Always cooked well. A little thin and a little light on sauce.