Nonnas Pizza

Sauce is very good. Owner is Italian. Irene says 9.0, rookie score

Classic "dollar slice" NYC style pizza. Great flavor in the sauce and cheese, and the perfect ratio. Good crust and a decent undercarriage. Almost too much flop, but it's got a good length-width ratio-makes for a good foldable slice. $4 a slice at a pretty sizable fair/festival (Southington Apple Harvest). Good value for the venue and quality. Easy 8/10

Top 2 Pizza places in Southington. Always a solid pizza and ownership is great.

Solid pizza. Good crust, good sauce, can be a bit cheesy sometimes, but quality is always consistent. Not quite a New Haven pie, but I still recommend trying it.

Solid pie with a nice crisp!

Okay at best, really floppy and soft

First visit after following for a while. I have to say it was worth the wait! I follow Dave on a daily bases and we need him to review this location. I always do a large cheese and review as I travel throughout New England. This is my first review I posted because I wanted to wait for “the one”, this checks all the boxes for me and I can assure any Dave followers this will hit the mark and give this guys a little south of here a run for their money! I ate 1/2 solo in about 5 mins🤘🏽

Honestly a damn good pie. Sauce has a nice tang, perfect amount cheese and the crust is perfect. Nothing to complain about here 🤙🤙

The best cheese pizza in CT

New haven style, great fresh cheese, nice crunchy crust, thin pizza, good taste

One the best pizzas I ever had… a little bit grainy and oaky… but I’m so glad they picked up at 8:45 to tell me to go kick rocks. Whoever answered the phone should be working at dominos and not a local pizza restaurant.

Called at 8:51 and was told they’re “closed”. Google clearly says takeout until 9:45. Unreal. Empty stomach and empty table

Small cheese

Great undercarriage with tasty tomato sauce. It was slightly chewy, about the only holding it back. Best pizza in Southington!

Good under carriage. Light sauce. Legit amount of cheese. Nice crust.

Great pie. A bit of a flop but the taste of the pie is great and the crust is outstanding. Will definitely eat again.

Good pie with good flavor. Crust is a bit soft and has a lot of flop. Overall a good pizza to order in, but wouldn’t travel for.

Wow, this place is a hidden gem. I ordered the cheese and also a Little Italy, both fantastic! Cooked to perfection, the sauce has good flavor, the right amount of cheese, perfect crisp and very little flop. The crust tasted like awesome Italian bread. I’ll be coming back again and again. The owner is very friendly and knows how to make a very good pie.

Tried cheese slice first. Minimal flop. Very little grease. Nice thin crust. Overall very good taste.