Disclaimer:Review based solely off the cheese slice, which was eaten first to ensure it was still fresh out of the oven. Alright Frankie, Pretty average slice for Long Island. Crust was super thin until about the last inch, where it got thick and very doughy. The cheese ratio to the thinness of the crust was too much cheese for me. Felt like i was just chewing a ball of mozzarella. Sauce was good but there wasn’t enough of it in my opinion. Other reviewers did Sicilian style and on that’s covered in a crazy amount of toppings, maybe that’s why they’re voting in the 8’s? This couldn’t break a 7 for me. It’s decent, and near my job. I’d go back, but i won’t be expecting it to be any better. That’s a review.
Order now on Slice
Order Nonna's Pizzeria
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
karl.groeger17/7/23, 6:59 p.m.
Fantastic margarita slice. Scores on app are low - really good place
andrew.demarco29/19/21, 1:12 p.m.
Super floppy pizza Fell right apart into a ball of mess And the sauce was terrible. This place went down hill
t-rex.pizza1/4/20, 1:10 a.m.
A little too bready and can use more sauce to elevate the score. The flavor was decent and staff is friendly.
daniel.dorazio9/6/19, 8:17 p.m.
Very chewy and floppy. No crispiness what so ever. The "Brooklyn marinara" was cold and chewy also. Not good. That's a D - review.
soddy26010/23/18, 9:16 p.m.
I like some flop with my pizza but this is too much. Lots of cheese-no sauce. Towards the crust I found some rigidness, not even to save the slice however.
dan.fiore9/6/18, 9:20 p.m.
Alright Frankie... Corner slice is always the go-to. Minimal grease, nice and fluffy dough. Nothing too heavy. Ok sauce to cheese ratio, could be a bit saucier. Amazing seasonings. Great spot for shopping center pizza. Always the spot while on break from work. Owner Jay is the MAN. Guy knows what he’s doing.