Warning new favorite pie!! Literally a 12 gauge to the wedding vegetables it hits you with so much and every ingredient compliments the next. The crust was charred like I love buttery like the greased up deff guy. Garlic like a mf all over. Cheese off the charts grated all over with no regard for excess. Sauce tho has to stand out above all here as I couldn’t get enough. Heavy pizza no flop on this upside down. Being from Jersey SI was the one place I could look down on but not anymore. If you try to clone this pizza and name it dolly they’d kill it and make it illegal.
pizza_reviews_on_the_go9/13/20, 9:06 a.m.
Nonna’s Upside down slice. 8.8 out of ten. That crust is perfect! Lots of cheese, grated cheese and naturally sweet sauce. No flop.
pizzaqueen073/18/20, 12:35 a.m.
Every slice I’ve had is solid. Great pizzeria. The upside down is the best slice they have. Tastes way better than it looks.
patrieek3/11/20, 3:59 a.m.
Overall good slice. Not the best, not the worst. Good quality neighborhood pizza.
shimmertime932/10/20, 11:59 a.m.
Their Vodka pie is very good. They use fresh mozzarella and you can taste the difference. The vodka sauce is very tasty. Their regular pie is very good but their vodka is better!
francis.jost11/5/19, 1:26 a.m.
Best pizza on Staten Island, bold statement I know..but I have never had a bad slice from Nonnas, their special slices are killer. Sweet red sauce, cheese is more that just mutz, & the crust always have great crunch
itsjimbofresh10/5/19, 11:04 p.m.
Well done bottom, crunchy and crispy. Cheese:sauce distribution is off, but works. Vodka slice is the best - but regular is solid too
richard.tymon8/10/19, 12:23 a.m.
I would drag my braciole through a mile of broken glass just to get a faint whiff of this sauce from a scratch and sniff
sal.greco5/4/19, 6:33 p.m.
If you are in great kills come in and try this pizza. The regular slice is good, but all the specialty slices are excellent! The 7.6 is just a score for a plain slice, but trust me the other slices are even better!
theleomar5/3/19, 4:50 p.m.
Alright, franky... Cheese lovers dream! Its got a yuge flop, but only cause the chunks of melted mozzarel weigh it down. Sauce is good, not acidy or tangy. Great crunch in the crust especially if you get it well done. Delicious!
thedraculadude24/18/19, 11:00 p.m.
Upside down slice. Solid 8. Not a rookie score because I thought about it a lot haha.
shaun.gaffney4/16/19, 4:16 p.m.
One of the hidden gems of Staten Island. Never gets brought up as one of the Islands heavy hitting pizza spots. I give it all the love in the world though. The sauce and cheese perfectly blend together to create an unbelievable slice. A true New York flop puts this with the pizza Gods. Check it out Pres you won’t be let down.
dan.masters13/29/19, 7:56 p.m.
Still a solid 9.1. I love this place! Crispy, tasty and delicious. Can’t wait to see what elPresidente, thinks.
listenupmanee3/25/19, 5:33 a.m.
Upside down slice was delicious, could have used more cheese. Great sauce.
matthew.giacobbe3/7/19, 12:26 a.m.
Crust was very good. Generous amount of cheese. Good slice.
michael.taliercio2/10/19, 2:39 a.m.
good pizza fresh just needed to be a little warmer family friends place magnificent service and food highly recommended
64 views•4 likes