Let me start by saying this pizza is really good. The crust tastes delicious and the sauce is slightly on the sweeter side. However, these were old slices, so they should have only been served to the help. This is probably due to what time I was in there: long after the lunch rush and before the dinner rush. Also, even though I asked him not to heat it up too much, he went to make a salad, then rung up some other guy, then went on his phone and left it for another guy to take out, and it still came out cold. And I have to point out that these are the worst looking regular slices I’ve reviewed so far; look at how far from the edge before you get to any sauce or cheese.
pizzaqueen073/18/20, 12:34 a.m.
Did not like the sauce. Had a hard time finishing. Crust was ok. Not the worst but would not ever have again. Overrated.
bkpizza1603/9/20, 11:42 p.m.
I have been meaning to try Nunzio’s for awhile and it did not disappoint. Great slice!!
anthony.caranante7/8/19, 11:32 p.m.
The sauce and cheese have a nice flavor. The dough could've been a little crispier. It was just a little dry. Overall Nunzio's has a solid slice.
jake.therattlesnake6/15/19, 6:36 p.m.
For a plain scilian. Ok. sucky cheese coverage. Sauce was good. Dough was a little over done
stephen.boundy6/15/19, 12:32 a.m.
Very solid slice but SO MUCH FLOP. Good flavor with a little tang
marc.san luis6/11/19, 10:08 p.m.
...excellent cheese pizza. Nice tasting sauce and excellent crust ...just the right cheese
stephen.dibari5/26/19, 5:24 p.m.
Delicious sauce and crunchy/crispy crust. Would’ve been in the low 8’s if the cheese was better. Cheese is lacking flavor
paulie_pizza5/6/19, 7:27 p.m.
Nice and thin. Pretty good crunch. Cheese is very good. Sauce slightly bland. Solid overall slice.
renren11294/6/19, 1:27 a.m.
The absolute pizza on Staten Island. Sauce is not too sweet, not too bitter, just right. The perfect amount of cheese to sauce to dough ratio. My go to spot for a quick slice or a pie for dinner!
michael.taliercio4/1/19, 6:56 p.m.
fresh mozz slice review- pretty good fresh mozz isn’t great but the sauce really brings the taste up of the pie solid
colie3/26/19, 2:51 a.m.
Good pizza but kinda bland. The dough is definitely the best part. Really nice crunch to it!
mauriciomaxmoncayo3/14/19, 7:24 p.m.
Crispy, incredible sauce, but there’s a tiny something missing about the cheese. Overall great slice, that other place “Brooklyn’s Finest Compost”... stay FAR AWAY from there. 🤣
40 views•2 likes
s.i.p.a3/3/19, 12:48 p.m.
2nd review. A little heavy handed with the sauce this time and the pie was a little bit of a mess. Crust was almost completely ripped off one slice. Gave it an 8.9 the first time and only knocking it down to an 8.7 because the taste was still there
halid.lika2/27/19, 7:26 p.m.
Good quality slice. The cheese was flavorful and the sauce was tangy and sweet, just the way I like it. The crust also had a good old fashioned taste to it, nice and crunchy.