Nunzio's Pizzeria

The pizza was fantastic - but I have to say that the staff is equally wonderful. Highly recommend and worth the 3 hr drive!

Great pizza The upside down Sicilian was amazing cooked perfectly and the sauce had great flavor 8.9 The sausage pie needed more sausage but still good 7.9

Amazing

NY Style Signature pie was crispy and delicious with a thin crust. Rice balls are also excellent.

Fabulous Pizza. In between a bar and NY style.

Excellent

Enjoyable pie. While it was solid, it was missing something for me. A little bland. Crust wasn’t my favorite, I prefer my sauce more sweet, cheese was good. Side note the service was excellent, the bread was really good, and the other menu items looked tasty.

All around excellent pie. Thin crust, but not the cracker-like texture you find at other top tier pies in the area. This still has some body to it. Great sauce and the sausage is the best sausage I’ve ever had on a pizza.

Good crisp, tastes good

Old school NY style pizzeria. Love the vibe, and great staff. Great crispy pizza. Would recommend if in the area.

This was just an ok pie. I feel like it didn’t have enough flavor. Another critique I have is there was nobody in the restaurant and it took about 30 minutes to get the pie. But other than that it was just ok.

An excellent classic NY pie. Great cheese and crust especially, with a ton of flavor.

Fantastic bar pizza. No flop, slight grease, perfect amount of cheese. Highly recommend!

Heavy on the cheese and was a bit soupy. Half plain half meatball, I prefer crumbled meatball not big slices. Should’ve went all plain for the review. Either way, was far from my favorite. Perhaps it died in the box, will have to eat in and give it another shot based on how highly rated it is. For now, 6.8.

OMG. As your ‘SauceDude’, the new pomodoro pie is a solid 10. However, I am rating the plain pie and I’m IN LOVE WITH IT. Hands down my favorite taste of a plain pie. Molly, our server who’s studying at temple, is amazing. She does it all - waits, cleans, register and even photographer! Great ambiance for a historic pizzeria! Two huge thumbs up on this plain pie - OH MY GOD 🍕

Thin, light crust but lacked some flavor in both he sauce and crust. A bit of salt and crushed red pepper helped.

The best sausage & mushroom pie 😊

This family owned pizzeria is a staple of the community. They make the best pies in town and it isn’t close. Flavors, crust and sauce is second to no one. If you consider yourself a pizza connoisseur then you need to add this to your list of stops this year. Lou and the Nunzio’s staff will give an unforgettable experience. Saluti!

Delectable

1/2 meatball, 1/2 peppers and onions = a perfect pie. Nunzio’s is consistent, delicious and a great place all around.

The best pizza in NJ (maybe in the world).

Easily some of the best pizza I have had the privilege of enjoying, not to mention the fantastic garlic knots which are the best I have ever had.