NY Pizza Suprema

Score is for the cheese slice. Very sauce-forward slice, which isn’t generally my thing. Chunks of tomatoes in there, and it’s pretty sweet. Cheese was OK, a little grease, and not nearly as good as I remembered. Decent crunch to the crust, airy at the ends. The pepperoni slice wasn’t as good — the combo of robust sauce and pepperoni was kind of overwhelming. 7.1 on the pepperoni slice.

Good Romano. Very wet slice. Tangy sauce.

Solid solid cheese slice. Upside down slice is where it’s at. Ask for their hot honey sauce to dip crust in.

Great sauce (sweet); great tomatoes; cheese tastes good, but separates; a little floppy; average dough; lots of flavor options.

Excellent grandma slice. Sauce is sweet, fluffy and crunchy base

Great flavor on this one. Sauce is seasoned right and is chunky.

Cheese slice Very good classic New Yorkers favorite. I would give the edge to Joe’s but really thin good crust. Sauce is missing something and cheese is a bit greasy but a very good slice

8.2 PREZ?!? Best slice in NYC without a doubt, it’s all about that sauce #iykyk

Hot af and burnt my mouth but perfect crunch, texture, with a nice layer of cheese. The cheese tended to break off but overall fantastic slice.

Solid slice

Best regular slice you’ll find.... perfectly cooked thin on the dough .... amazing sauce a little on the sweet side...above average cheese

This was the supreme slice, wow. Incredible.

I almost walked out because the slices sitting behind the glass looked anything but fresh but WOW would that have been a huge mistake ! The first slice of my short review life that I savored every bite of. Great char, tangy chunky sauce on the sweet side and just enough grease that it perfectly complimented the super crunchy crust. I’m coming back !

A damn good NYC slice. The crust is excellent; delicious and crispy. The sauce is prominent and flavorful. The cheese isn’t particularly amazing, but well balanced. Great slice! Definitely try it.

This is New York style pizza..

EXCELLENT slice- came back and got two plain pies. The sauce has a great tang and it’s perfectly crispy. Good even a day later!

The OG pepperoni is the way to go

Great taste to the cheese and sauce. Slight flop, but needs more crisp. With good crisp, it’d be easily into the 8s

Long-time favorite. And next to Penn Station which is the perfect welcome or tasty farewell from the city. Every time.

Sauce is great

🤤

Ranked 8th Best Slice in the World by Big Travel 7. This slice was jam packed with flavor. There was minimal flop. A thinker than average slice with a lot of cheese and a super crispy crust.