NY Pizza Suprema

One of the best in NY

Get the Sicilian.

Thin crispy

Buffalo chicken slice

Best slice in NYC, hands down

Solid but my slice was burnt

Score is for the cheese slice. Very sauce-forward slice, which isn’t generally my thing. Chunks of tomatoes in there, and it’s pretty sweet. Cheese was OK, a little grease, and not nearly as good as I remembered. Decent crunch to the crust, airy at the ends. The pepperoni slice wasn’t as good — the combo of robust sauce and pepperoni was kind of overwhelming. 7.1 on the pepperoni slice.

Good Romano. Very wet slice. Tangy sauce.

Solid solid cheese slice. Upside down slice is where it’s at. Ask for their hot honey sauce to dip crust in.

Great sauce (sweet); great tomatoes; cheese tastes good, but separates; a little floppy; average dough; lots of flavor options.

Excellent grandma slice. Sauce is sweet, fluffy and crunchy base

Great flavor on this one. Sauce is seasoned right and is chunky.

Cheese slice Very good classic New Yorkers favorite. I would give the edge to Joe’s but really thin good crust. Sauce is missing something and cheese is a bit greasy but a very good slice

8.2 PREZ?!? Best slice in NYC without a doubt, it’s all about that sauce #iykyk

Hot af and burnt my mouth but perfect crunch, texture, with a nice layer of cheese. The cheese tended to break off but overall fantastic slice.

Solid slice

Best regular slice you’ll find.... perfectly cooked thin on the dough .... amazing sauce a little on the sweet side...above average cheese