This score is blended. The upside down square (only the 2nd place I’d choose a square over a regular slice) is a way better slice...not even remotely close. Probably a 9.5. The regular slice is an 8.0 - still really good but for some reason I can’t understand, they use a different sauce and that is the difference.
blake.zamjahn5/15/21, 6:32 p.m.
Cheese pizza = 8.8 Chicken parm pizza = 8.4 Overall score = 8.8 Friendly people and nice environment
sean.mcdonnell33/6/21, 9:55 p.m.
Score is for the cheese slice. Very sauce-forward slice, which isn’t generally my thing. Chunks of tomatoes in there, and it’s pretty sweet. Cheese was OK, a little grease, and not nearly as good as I remembered. Decent crunch to the crust, airy at the ends. The pepperoni slice wasn’t as good — the combo of robust sauce and pepperoni was kind of overwhelming. 7.1 on the pepperoni slice.
maenu2/16/21, 12:17 a.m.
Solid solid cheese slice. Upside down slice is where it’s at. Ask for their hot honey sauce to dip crust in.
funky.pizza.lover2/6/21, 5:39 a.m.
Great sauce (sweet); great tomatoes; cheese tastes good, but separates; a little floppy; average dough; lots of flavor options.
greg.keely1/29/21, 6:13 p.m.
Great flavor on this one. Sauce is seasoned right and is chunky.
janis1/10/21, 6:47 p.m.
Cheese slice Very good classic New Yorkers favorite. I would give the edge to Joe’s but really thin good crust. Sauce is missing something and cheese is a bit greasy but a very good slice
sevvy12/20/20, 2:51 p.m.
8.2 PREZ?!? Best slice in NYC without a doubt, it’s all about that sauce #iykyk
matt.braaten12/7/20, 2:11 p.m.
Hot af and burnt my mouth but perfect crunch, texture, with a nice layer of cheese. The cheese tended to break off but overall fantastic slice.
6 views•0 likes