OK peeps. I usually despise grabbing a slice anywhere near Broadway and midtown because I’m usually severely unimpressed. But this time you got me. Touché! As soon as you walk in it’s littered with pictures of celeb chefs who probably got the back door VIP treatment and MSG. Decided to sneak across the street for a slice, good move. The place has been around since the late 60s rightfully so. Pictures of everybody from Rachel ray to chef Curtis and many others. Will now be the only place I stopped to get a slice before catching a next or Rangers game. Onto the pizza. The slice was the perfect width. Nice and crispy throughout. Perfect crunch. No New York flop. The sauce on the slice was nice and tasty. Not too much not too little. Great tasting cheese not overwhelming and not shitty cheap stuff. Just great flavor throughout. Now I’ve tasted a lot better but you’re one of the good ones Pal.. congrats.... bonus review. I also decided to get a fri divolo with peperoni Sicilian...It was friggin great. Sauce was amazing with the spice of pepperoni though was perfect nice and crispy buttery. Actually better than the regular slice. So for the regular slice I give you an 8.1 and for the Special Sicilian you get an 8.8
Order now on Slice
Order NY Pizza Suprema
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
jtrap5/4/22, 3:47 a.m.
Never made a review for this spot, but it is one of the best traditional New York slices in the city. Right behind Joe’s in my opinion. Chunky tomato sauce is great. Got a bit of darkened crust underneath. Also has a great variety of slices to go with if you want something different.
t-rex.pizza4/21/22, 10:08 p.m.
This slice was as hot as Sun and took the roof of my mouth clean off!!!! The slice was super fresh and tasty, with the sauce being the star! A really nice a thin crust, combined with a perfect char and great crisp defined the score. The flop from an extraordinary amount of cheese kept it from elite level, but nonetheless worth the trip.
aj.labella3/30/22, 12:27 a.m.
This pizza is so good that a few simple fixes might put it into the 9s. The sauce is delicious and sweet BUT it wasn't quite evenly distributed. Some bites were all sauce. Some bites were all cheese. But a little too much cheese throughout made it slightly too greasy. Crust was fantastic. Crispy. Minimal flop.
d-pizza2/3/22, 5:04 a.m.
They were out of plain, so I got some others that were close. Slices were between $6-7.50 each, which is insane. Nothing special. I recall that the plain is better, but if they don’t have it, it’s on them. Probably will never repeat.
fratrick12/27/21, 9:51 p.m.
Thin crust, great sauce and poppin cheese. Big slice but def one of the better ones