isabella.williamson9/15/21, 10:33 p.m.
BEST PIZZA EVER!! I decided to stop in to ny pizza suprema on my way back from class as I was starving, I walked in and was immediately greeted by the lovely staff!!!! Overwhelmed with all of the delicious choices, I decided to go with the creamy potato and the upside down slice! Although a little on the pricier side it was worth EVERY PENNY! Best pizza I ever put in my mouth, I will probably be returning every day from here on out !!! 😘 they really do know how to make a delicious slice, can’t wait to try the hot and spicy 😉
tj.gonen8/14/21, 9:41 p.m.
Are you people out of your mind ?? This pizza is basic AF and not even good. And the price ?? Most expensive pizza EVER. This thing is so disappointing
mh423988/13/21, 3:39 p.m.
Great slice, more consistent than Rose’s (RIP). $4 for a plain slice kinda steep though
lbpizza8/8/21, 2:48 a.m.
Always have a pie ready, u already know that gets it to at least 7.1. A bit more cheese would’ve got it to 7.9+ territory, still a solid undercarriage and a great crust. 7.4 is a fair score, quality New York pizza
mmmmkrey7/14/21, 11:35 p.m.
Large slices and a wide variety of options! Great for a quick lunch or dinner. Dave’s score was quite generous but very good pizza!
jacob.lehr7/5/21, 2:04 p.m.
This is a solid slice. Your classic New York slice. Crust is delicious, but so is most crust in the city. Nothing really stands out to put it over the top. Nonetheless, this is a great slice and really epitomizes the NY slice.
adam.baltaxe7/3/21, 2:27 a.m.
My first slice was an 8 and my second was an 8.4 so I averaged it to a solid 8.2 with very good cheese.
pizzavampire6/14/21, 4:26 p.m.
Place located diagonal from MSG has about 20 different slices to choose from. I got the meat lovers, which had great ratio and flavor. A lot of flop but not greasy at all. Could have made the 9’s on a crispier day.
jtm27276/12/21, 1:47 a.m.
Prices have gone up, but still a very solid slice. Crispy crust, tangy cheese, and great tomato sauce. Not my absolute favorite slice, but a must-visit for the neighborhood and for anyone going to MSG or Penn Station. A rare find in a pizza desert.
etuero5/26/21, 5:05 p.m.
Pretty good slice of pizza . Not 8.2 good but its decent . Tasty good under carriage nice crisp
tree_washer5/25/21, 9:13 p.m.
Two plain slices fresh out of the oven. Crust was excellent with good flavor and a magic blend of being chewy and crispy. Cheese blend is good - they don’t seem to be skimping on their mozzarella - and the thicker twists of cheese produced a great melt. The sauce was the only thing that led me to knock some points off; it just seemed bit ordinary in comparison to the rest of the pie. I’ll definitely go back.