The sign out front claimed "#1 slice in New York" so I don't know how you pass up that opportunity. Unfortunately I really doubt that's true, although it was a really quality slice with good crisp and solid tasting sauce. Right outside MSG/Penn & would absolutely stop again on the way to the stadium/train. Specialty slices looked decent, but very expensive. I guess that's what you're gonna get out of that area
Order now on Slice
Order NY Pizza Suprema
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
kevin.price11/15/21, 9:57 p.m.
Upside down Sicilian and damn what a light pillowy amazing crunchy slice robust seasoned chunky sauce topped with grated cheese sets this off! The cheese pull from underneath is stuff of legends and the taste of the crunchy crust is legendary.
tommyg68810/14/21, 9:47 p.m.
Stopped here before the Blueshirts game. Fresh out of oven all I can say I wow. Great crust zero flop. Thin but not cracker thin. On the saucy side but I like that. Perfect amount of delicious cheese.
zzpizzadog10/9/21, 10:00 p.m.
This is New York Pizza. Big slices, crisp crust that folds, gooey cheese, loud, wonderful. Perfect amount of sauce, great variety of different slices. My score is so high because everything about the place from the tin pans to the slices in the window you point at to the men in blue mauling slices between patrols just tastes like New York and New York just tastes like pizza.
socaltw10/3/21, 5:54 p.m.
Starting a day of pizza reviews with the trusty dusty Pizza Suprema right next to MSG. This is the first place a brought T to in NYC! Once again it didn’t disappoint !!
ascher10/3/21, 5:07 p.m.
The cheese was incredible. Great crispy undercarriage and the crust may have been the best part.
hendu9/27/21, 10:53 p.m.
Went in for a slice, when they took the slice and threw it in the oven to be honest I didn’t expect much because the pie didn’t look that fresh. But I was pleasantly surprised with a delicious slice that had an awesome crispness to the crust and a delicious sauce. No doubt the best slice around Penn Station.
matthew.kelly39/16/21, 9:45 p.m.
Other slices looked better then plain tbh, might have just got a bad batch but I thought it was just a notch above average
isabella.williamson9/15/21, 10:33 p.m.
BEST PIZZA EVER!! I decided to stop in to ny pizza suprema on my way back from class as I was starving, I walked in and was immediately greeted by the lovely staff!!!! Overwhelmed with all of the delicious choices, I decided to go with the creamy potato and the upside down slice! Although a little on the pricier side it was worth EVERY PENNY! Best pizza I ever put in my mouth, I will probably be returning every day from here on out !!! 😘 they really do know how to make a delicious slice, can’t wait to try the hot and spicy 😉
tj.gonen8/14/21, 9:41 p.m.
Are you people out of your mind ?? This pizza is basic AF and not even good. And the price ?? Most expensive pizza EVER. This thing is so disappointing
mh423988/13/21, 3:39 p.m.
Great slice, more consistent than Rose’s (RIP). $4 for a plain slice kinda steep though
lbpizza8/8/21, 2:48 a.m.
Always have a pie ready, u already know that gets it to at least 7.1. A bit more cheese would’ve got it to 7.9+ territory, still a solid undercarriage and a great crust. 7.4 is a fair score, quality New York pizza