Dough was chewy, crust not crunchy, pizza was thin. I expected more and it was just good.
Order now on Slice
Order NYPD Pizza
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
floridascott10/13/21, 11:19 p.m.
Pizza review time here in Orlando. This place is called NYPD pizza, with everything totally NY inside. 1. I walked in and ask the girl about the franchise sign, ( just curious if there were more than one place) she thought I was looking to open up one of these places. 2. This is not related to NYPD pizza in Boynton Beach, which is on my list to check, from a recommendation. 3. Texture of the crust was strange, not that authentic. Had a little grease dripping. Sauce was so so. Cheese was very good.
zmannn7/16/21, 11:45 p.m.
Cheese and sauce was good, but dough was soft and mush needed to be crispy it would make a big difference.
the251reaper3/18/21, 10:18 p.m.
Delicious pizza with a great sauce. The ranch, mariners and garlic dipping sauce tastes house made versus shipped in. Great customer service, perhaps the greatest. Only thing needing improvement is the crust was a little soft and could use a bit more backbone.
robby.wander3/14/21, 1:45 a.m.
The cheese pizza met my expectations. Simple as that. The garlic knots, meatballs, and craft beer definitely help reinforce this establishment as a good spot for a meal when in the Shingle Creek area of Orlando.
spider-man2pizzatime3/12/21, 8:48 p.m.
Nice thin and crispy crust. Nice flop. Little grease. Sauce has good flavor. Could’ve used a little bit more cheese though.
michael.mcdonald612/5/20, 1:43 p.m.
Cheese was cooked perfectly and the sauce reminded me of pizza back in NY but the crust could have been much crispier. Too much flop.
dan.davis190211/24/20, 12:10 a.m.
Had a tasty sauce but could have used more of it. Hit the spot and rapid delivery got to us when we needed it. Not mind blowing but rock solid pizza, delivered to a resort.
taylor.dufrane7/10/20, 5:52 p.m.
It’s a good thinner pizza. Good flop really tasty, could have gotten closer to the 8s if there was a bit less grease. Worth a try
13 views•0 likes
poitras2/12/20, 5:36 p.m.
Not NY pizza but still good regardless. Lots of flop, great cheese and crust, average sauce
13 views•3 likes
lynzee.m2/12/20, 5:21 p.m.
Not New York pizza but there is So much flop. The cheese was really good. I didn’t hate anything about it. Best pizza I’ve had in awhile
vapizzakingva2/12/20, 5:18 p.m.
Stellar flop factor, just greasy enough, easily best slice in Orlando Crust is lacking a bit
amordepizza1/6/20, 7:46 p.m.
I’m from NYC and I’m insulted that this is considered NY pizza. Dollar pizza is better than this, I had better pizza at sea world than I did at this place. The pizza came out cold, the cheese was bland, the sauce was lacking. Order dominoes to your hotel than coming here.
asianpizzadude12/12/19, 12:07 a.m.
Good not bad. Sauce needs work but if you're hungry and in the area give it a go
10 views•1 like
ray.rivera11/4/19, 11:25 p.m.
Decent. Not even close to NY, but for Florida it is ok. - Nice size slice - Light Crisp - Crust was decent - Could barley taste the sauce - Consistency was good - Definitely not New York - Kind of bland - Overall OK - Not as greasy as other reviews - 6.6
14 views•0 likes
jamal.atta9/16/19, 10:25 p.m.
Bland, and really just not great. Too doughy and greasy for no flavor