One Bite App | Pizza Review App by Barstool Sports
Download
Home
Top Restaurants
NYPD Pizza

NYPD Pizza

2589 South Hiawassee Road, Orlando, Florida
11 views•0 likes
chadly_17 on One Bite Pizza App

chadly_17

6/7/20 5:03 PM

Pizza Review
jeff.schuman10/23/25, 11:39 p.m.
Pizza review

7.8

Felt a lil spicy tonight so I got the pepps and basil! Good sized Pie! Cooked just rite! Good crisp! Nice undercarriage! 0 Flop! Good sauce! Good cheese! Prices are very good! Great all around pie! Will def be back!!
0 likes
Pizza Review
elwyn4/21/25, 4:11 a.m.
Pizza review

7.7

0 likes
Pizza Review
abeetzwolf6/1/22, 1:05 a.m.
Pizza review

6.8

Service was excellent. They make their pies on a circulating pizza oven, never have seen anything like it.
0 likes
Pizza Review
jmoze5/5/22, 10:11 p.m.
Pizza review

6.3

1 like
Pizza Review
markizzle2/19/22, 6:41 p.m.
Pizza review

7.3

Great cheese and great sauce absolutely amazing pie
0 likes
Pizza Review
lou.cacio1/18/22, 9:16 p.m.
Pizza review

7.0

Crust was ok, but probably good because I tried a slice and it was reheated. The pizza lacked flavor in the sauce and I feel could use more sauce in general. Overall just ok.
0 likes
Pizza Review
joey.carattini6/30/21, 7:27 p.m.
Pizza review

6.0

Ok not great
0 likes
Pizza Review
webev1/18/20, 12:34 a.m.
Pizza review

8.0

I’ve got a lot of complaints. The service was pretty bad. It took very long to make. It’s not even NY style pizza, it’s more football pizza. That being said, the pizza itself was fantastic.
0 likes
Pizza Review
joey.marsiano11/7/19, 5:32 p.m.
Pizza review

5.6

Very fair. Back in the day and at a different location it was better.
1 like
Pizza Review
clifford.horvath10/19/19, 4:29 p.m.
Pizza review

6.9

1 like
Pizza Review
katiekelly268/9/19, 11:25 p.m.
Pizza review

5.3

0 likes
Pizza Review
ethan.brickwood3/9/19, 7:17 p.m.
Pizza review

3.6

It’s not lookin good dan.
100 views•2 likes
Pizza Review
misteronetime1/9/19, 4:08 p.m.
Pizza review

6.0

Definitely don’t go to Florida looking for pizza but when you search top restaurants on Trip Advisor and this place consistently pops up as the #2 place in the Orlando area, you kinda feel obligated! Did the pepperoni and half Italian sausage. I don’t normally do pepperoni but what the hell. Overall it was not greasy so that’s a plus. Crust had a decent flop and flavor. Cheese and sauce were pretty basic. Overall this pizza was ok. I’d eat it again but doesn’t come close to the top of my list. And this is definitely a prime example of how reviews are relative to location. Floridians obviously have little experience with what good pizza taste like. If they do, then they are most likely a transplant from Chicago or the greater New York area.
0 likes
Pizza Review
twobit10/1/18, 12:33 a.m.
Pizza review

2.8

TERRIBLE PIZZA, crust is rock hard, sauce is decent, cheese is meh. Avoid!
1 like
(407) 293-8880
2589 South Hiawassee Road
Orlando, Florida 32835
Something not look right?
Suggest an Edit
Barstool Bets - Barstool Gambling
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • YouTube

© 2026 Barstool Sports. All rights reserved.

Terms of UsePrivacy PolicyContent PolicyContact UsApp Support