New York Pizza & Pasta - Tamiami

So here it is, my highest score in 2 weeks that I've been in the Fort Myers/ Cape Coral/ Naples area. 1. I was driving route 41 and stopped off and found this place on the one bite pizza app. I wanted to make sure while I was in this area, that I am not missing any good places, while I'm in this area. Well, this place right now is at 8.0 average which is extremely high score. 2. The place was pretty packed in the late afternoon, at the time I made it there. Watching the staff, they were like a well-oiled machine, very efficient. 3. Out of my many many Pizza reviews I've done recently, this one by far had the thickest cheese that I've had in quite a while. Overall it may not be a New York standard, but to me it takes it up a few notches. The sauce and the dough both had very good flavor to it. I really want to give some of the local places an 8.1 and higher but I still am yet to find it.

Place is amazing. Pasta was also fantastic.

solid, non exemplary slices. crust was not too floppy and had some mild crunch. flavor profile of dough and sauce didn’t pop but the cheese was portioned and cooked well.

Originally from NYC, this is really good for FL Standards but they only do slices before 3pm.

Looks good. Floppy. Decent undercarriage. Slight crunch. Taste is sweet to slightly blandish. Decent but not my favorite in the area.

Amazing pizza & cocktails !! Great Vibes.

The best New York style pizza in Naples. Period.

New York Pizza & Pasta certainly didn’t disappointed and lived up to its claim. The pizza is made with fresh homemade dough and hand tossed & stretched to create that New York-style pizza crust. Little flop and evenly cooked made this pizza place one to come back to. The service was a 10.

Had to try the Grandmas. Good quality ingredients. Good crisp.

Very good basic New York style pizza

When the say "traditional" they aren't messing around. Great pie. Excellent sauce and not too much cheese. Just right. A little greasy, but I mean that in a good way. Excellent dough and a crisp crust. Well done, NYPP!

Savory & delicious. New York Pizza & Pasta is a true Naples gem for local New York Style pizza lovers. Service has been friendly, accommodating our large party on a moments notice. Staff are following safety guidelines making our experience a positive on every level. I give the taste & service an A+. I am especially impressed with the cauliflower crust pesto pizza but everything I have sampled on the menu has been great! I highly recommend making New York Pizza & Pasta your next dining stop.

Great pizza, everything was perfect even distributed with sauce and cheese, perfectly cooked, highly recommend

Originally from New York, it’s hard to find a true New York slice of pizza in SWFL. But after recently checking out New York Pizza and Pasta, it’s no longer the case. Great pizza, perfect fold to the hard crust, tasty, and great service. Can’t wait to come back!

Happy National Pepperoni Pizza Day! And New York Pizza and Pasta did not disappoint!! Delicious NY style pizza, crunchy with tasty pepperoni... that’s the one that has a little kick at the end. Will come back for more of this!!!!

Best pizza in Naples so far!

One of my favorites spots in the area. Pretty consistent pizza week in and week out. Although, I typically enjoy their Sicilian by far. Enjoy! 😎

Thsi is the best pizza in Napels I have had so far.

Classic football style pizza. New York flop and greasy

Outstanding Slice. Doesn’t quite live with the gods. Look at that New York Flop.

Part 2

All right Frankie, one bite everybody knows the rules. Major flop, no crisp, no crunch, cheese ok, best part was the sauce.