This spot is a collaboration between Colony Pizza and McGarrey’s Oakwood Cafe (Irish restaurant) so the pizza is almost exactly the same as Colony. It does seem a little different and I can’t quite figure out what’s different about it. Maybe a different oven? Different folks making it so it’s slightly off. Whatever the case, it’s still pretty good. I’ve had them three times so far and have enjoyed it every time. The shape on this one kinda got away from whoever was making it but the taste was there. They have a late night drive thru slice window that I have yet to try but it seems like exactly what this town needs.
I hear the Reuben pizza is good. I’ll probably never try it because I’m picky but give it a shot!
