Oath Pizza - Nantucket

Pres was right this is really good, albeit bougie, pizza. We had the muffle trushroom pizza which had truffle, cheese and mushrooms on it. I didn’t try the plain pizza, but I’d have to assume it’s really good as well. Overall flavor on the pizza I tried was really good, especially if you like truffles and mushrooms. The crust wasn’t doughy but a far cry from a thin crust wood fired pizza. This is a great spot on a great island, definitely somewhere to grab a quick bite if you’re on island. 8.2 solid pizza, that’s a review.

The ambiance of this review was by far the most intriguing. A small stand sitting on the wharf in the center of Nantucket. Another perk is how fast everything is made right in front of you. The crust was the best part of this pie. Was like eating Funnel cake that you would get at a carnival. Only problem is that I felt the cheese and sauce were on a carnival as well. The crust was the best I’ve ever so still a strong pizza.

I ordered a full David The crust was pre-made but it came out fairly good

Good pizza

Cheese too stiff. Great crust and sauce! Luau pizza is great too

Came here cause of Dave’s 9+ review and wasn’t disappointed. I loved the vibe inside, so great watching them make my pie too. Order a whole of half, I did a half for travel. Super fresh ingredients, flash cooked the thing in no time! I personally would’ve loved a little more crisp from crust to tip of the slice, but overall very impressed. Would definitely grab again!

Lived up to the hype ❌🧢

Unfortunately ran into a bit of a thunder storm on the way to eat this beautiful pie but it still closes as my #1 on island. Must eat

This makes dominos look good. Ignore all good reviews, this is not good pizza.

Good pizza the crust is almost like fried dough but not really. They have variety. My girl and I got a “David” and a “spicy mother trucker”. I liked the spicy much better than the David. It was sirirachi rather than usual Buffalo hot sauce which still worked. El prez May have been a little too generous to this place but it is right off the ferry and it’s a long ride completely understandable because it hits the spot and does the job.

Really tasty , great cheese and very good crust. The sauce is different and really delicious. Absolute must if your on Nantucket.

This is amazing pizza. I am considering taking the hy-line back to Nantucket just to get more of this pizza. The half pie option is cool, but it’s basically the same size as a large single NY slice, except you get more crust. The crust is the most incredible crust I’ve ever had. Perfect crunch and consistency. Hard to imagine how they pull this off. Extremely cool location on the docks. I will be hunting high and low to find pizza like this again

9.3?? I mean come on prez!

Spicy Mother Clucker - solid half pie for 7 bones

Not bad. Cheese was great. Crust was awesome. Sauce has little flavor

Chewy crust...pretty tasty.