Oath Pizza - Nantucket

Oath Pizza on Nantucket. Dave’s infamous “crust fund baby” video. He had given them a 9.2 but I believe some Alcohol consumption had something to do with that score. This pizza had a very over powering olive oil taste that I’ve never had with another pizza. 7.6 is fair.

Good crust

Great pizza, this was a personal thin crust cheese. Crisp bottom, super flavorful mozzarella blend and tomato sauce.

Graz… the pizza man!

Terrible pizza. Huge flop, tasted burnt but the softest crust ever.

Solid.

The Pizza is amazing, if you go to Nantucket, go to Oath! It was delicious

Fantastic pie, after ordering was told that the thin crust with pepperoni was the way to go. Will definitely be back soon!

One bite. Solid solid. Crust is the best part. Pictured is pepp, but basing it off cheese I had. Has to be best on island

Interesting… the crust is pre-cooked, and deep fried in avocado oil. Makes it like fried dough. Toppings added cold, and put through conveyor for 2 mins. Sauce was great, toppings great. Never would have believed it…but really good.

Zesty sauce, interesting undercarriage. Certainly overhyped but not bad at all. Middle of the road pie.

Perfect crisp. Best hangover pie ever.

A little flop, crispy crust, very good sauce, pizza was very light, fluffy…. Very delicious…. Excellent pizza

Way over hyped

Thin crispy crust, great curled peps, decent pizza sauce that even has a little kick. Light on the cheese and cheese was not very impressive. Enough to ding this pie a full point in my book. Of the Oaths I have been to, this is probably lower middle of the pack.

This score is generous. Dave’s review is ridiculous. He must have been very high or hoping to get free pizza when on the island. The crust is almost light a crusty croissant. The sauce and cheese were okay.

was dave sober when he made this review?

Pizza was in the 7’s garlic bread was 8.1. Dough fried in avocado oil, was very solid.