Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom

Nothing to write home about. It’s open late. Lots of flop. No crisp. Below average pizza

Not really feeling this pizza. Ain’t close to anything good that’s on a Chicago level. It’s a little better than my Casey’s Mendoza line (5.0) at least

Half cheese half sausage Chicago thick Crust. Review based on sausage slice. Very cheesy. Right amount of sauce. Lots of crust but for this pizza it is a good think. Generous amounts of sausage but not overdone. No flop. Bottom is done well. Good crunch on the crust. No tang to the sauce like their marinara. Very filling.

I was expecting Chicago style. This is not Chicago style. Still better than Quad Cities style. Kind of doughy. Decent drunk pizza. A step up from Pizza Hut.

One of our favorite places to eat in Peoria! Solid pizza!

We always love Old Chicago! We got the Italian Grinder. Good amount of toppings, love the pepperoncinis! They have such good crust, buttery and fluffy. Only negative was it could have used more sauce but overall such a flavorful pizza!