So the slice I eat given was old...however it was still pretty good. The sauce had a little spice taste to it...a little too much oregano or something...but it was a decent NY slice....not as good as Johnny's up the street but still good. I'll give it a 6.8
alfasario3/21/21, 2:15 p.m.
This is a good pizza. So far best football pizza I’ve ha din Louisville. Good crust had a good cook on it good crunch very very slight flop. Right amount of cheese and with a good flavor. The sauce was good aswell I think it needed a little more sauce. But the bites that had nice pockets of sauce were great. I think had it had a little more sauce it would be an 8. But a little light on the sauce. Had to go with 7.6. This place has the right thing going on. If I lived here as of now this would be my Friday night pizza spot.
jacob.gray11/5/20, 4:45 p.m.
Sauce has an amazing flavor and when you bite into it you get a nice crispy bottom. With a crispy crust. Dave would approve
sean.payne9/4/20, 6:44 p.m.
Cheeseburger slice and the classic cheese slice. This place is by far my favorite in the Louisville area and is very similar to the pizza I’ve had in NYC. Today’s pizza was perfectly crispy and great as always. I do however wish they’d put on a little more sauce. You can barely taste sauce on their normal portion so I always have to add a little for myself. When ordering a whole pie, I always include the extra sauce option and it comes out perfect.
andrew.nevins4/28/20, 12:52 a.m.
Delivery driver pizza review #2. This is the best pie I’ve had in the ville. Takes me back to NYC.
27 views•2 likes
t.h44/11/20, 8:33 p.m.
Crust texture and cooking was right on. Flavors in cheese and sauce could use a little more bang.
bigtasty5022/19/20, 2:39 a.m.
Name says it all. This is exactly how I remember New York style pizza. Crispier crust, which im sure you can request, and we would've been in the 7's
tj.best2/8/20, 12:56 a.m.
Best pizza in Louisville, hands down! Have been coming here for about 3years. Massive pizzas, and can’t forget the garlic knots!
13 views•4 likes
bob.donovan1/8/20, 12:40 a.m.
Nice thin crust NY pizza done the way east coasters crave. A bit expensive though. $17 for a large cheese pie + they want a tip for takeout.
rick.carullo1/4/20, 12:13 a.m.
Good New York style pizza. Good crust! No Flop. The sauce has a bit of a twang but not much. Good pizza. I recommend them very much!!! Good New York Style slice.
bill.cherep12/8/19, 7:51 p.m.
Maybe high in the 8’a but I’ve been away from NYC for too long, this is the ONLY New York Pizza in Louisville. I’ve tried them all. Also, try their Philly Cheesesteak place across the street.
cpratt137/20/19, 10:56 p.m.
You know I feel like my last rating was a bit high. But this one is dead on! Great pie, and maybe I was swayed by the price too, tough to beat the Za here, impossible to beat the price!
steve.summitt7/16/19, 4:38 p.m.
Pretty good. Crispy, good sauce. Price wasn’t bad. If it were fresh, we may in a different world here. But pretty good overall. I’d come back!
carl.mack6/28/19, 12:18 a.m.
Got the Hawaiian. Prettt food taste but the crust and after taste remind me of Papa Johns. I’d be shocked if it’s not the same crust recipe.
tomatoman6/26/19, 7:32 p.m.
New York floppin’ into your heart. Crust has he perfect crunch, not hard, not chewy. Sauce and cheese are average.
jlang6/26/19, 7:31 p.m.
Great crust, make me bust. Very solid pizza. Not to heavy, not to greasy.