Old School NY Pizza

Must be ordered well done to get to a 7.3 Good flavor!

Great service, nice people, crispy crust, good flavor. 7.2

This place def gave me some East Coast NY/NJ vibes. The pizza was just as good as your average slice from your local joint down the Jersey Shore which means it’s probably one of the best you’ll see in Kentucky.

Good crisp, but the sauce lacks that certain tang I’m looking for in a classic NY slice. Very friendly staff…nice spot.

Decent pie, center of the pizza was a complete disaster. The last say four inches had great flavor and crust texture. Light on the sauce, it’s a subtle tasting affair. Pepperoni was nice and crispy. I suspect a refired single slice might be the way to go here… it would reduce the flop and hopefully the insane amount of oil sitting on top of the pizza … it just destroyed the undercarriage 🫤

Really, really good pizza. Thin, crispy undercarriage. Good sauce. Good cheese. Also got a pizza with toppings that was very good. Cannot go wrong here. Will be back.

Crisp was good tasty undercarriage , very good wish the sauce was little better tasted kinda bland but good in all

Solid crust. Subtle sauce to cheese ratio. Perfect representation of NY style pizza

Old school New York, Louisville Kentucky

Very light. This one was their Norton Commons location

Forgot to take a picture of the pizza but it was pretty solid. Cheese was really good, the sauce wasn’t my favorite but overall a pretty good slice.

Very good pizza. Crust was thin and crunchy with fresh cheese. Garlic knots were great.

It’s a nice NY style pizza with plenty of cheese and pepperoni. The crust is crispy and the undercarriage is thin and a little flop to it. The sauce does have a hint of sweetness to it but overall it’s a good pie

Nice pizza. Tasty sauce. Nice crisp crust 👍🏻

Crispy, sauce has a tang to it, great cheese. All around a solid pizza

This is a good pizza. So far best football pizza I’ve ha din Louisville. Good crust had a good cook on it good crunch very very slight flop. Right amount of cheese and with a good flavor. The sauce was good aswell I think it needed a little more sauce. But the bites that had nice pockets of sauce were great. I think had it had a little more sauce it would be an 8. But a little light on the sauce. Had to go with 7.6. This place has the right thing going on. If I lived here as of now this would be my Friday night pizza spot.

Best pizza I’ve had in Louisville

Sauce has an amazing flavor and when you bite into it you get a nice crispy bottom. With a crispy crust. Dave would approve