Olisi's New York Style

This is their $43.00 delivered, taxes, tip, etc…20” specialty meat deluxe house pizza, with Pepperoni, bacon, ham, meatball and sausage. I can see the pepperoni, everything else is a shredded up mess with cheese and sauce. Very disappointing, I’ve eaten pizza in many states. It wasn’t horrible, but I would give it a 5 of ten at best, and that would be if you are only very hungry or never had good pizza!

This is probably the closest thing I’ve had to NYC style pizza in Buffalo. The sauce is tangy and sweet. They nailed the best of both worlds

By far some of the best pizza in Buffalo. Definitely worth traveling over 20 minutes for because there’s isn’t much other good pizza around. I’ve had better NY style slices before, but not in the Buffalo area. If you’re tired of Buffalo style pizza then come here.

Solid slice. Tangy sauce is my jam!

I love New York style pizza not a lot of flop a lot of sauce good amount of cheese I would go back

One of the best undercarriages I’ve seen in a pie. This has the classic ny style flavor. The cheese is solid, and it’s not overly greasy. The only thing holding this pizza back is the sauce. I could tell from the smell of the pizza that the sauce wouldn’t be anything special. The sauce is quite bland, and is what this pie is lacking. Other than that I cannot complain. The crust is very nice and I am happy with this pie.

Really solid crust

A little flop, great crispy crust and the taste was good.

Flop had some good char at the bottom of the crust, sauce slightly on the sweet side, it’s a good slice.

Thinner crust “New York” style pizza. Greasy, flat pepperoni, good cheese, nice crunch in the crust, and sweeter sauce. Over all good slice of pizza. Above average.

Grabbed to-go slices, really good with the reheat. Crisp was fantastic, bit greasy but enjoyable. Real solid thin slice, rarely found in WNY.

As basic as it gets but that dose t mean bad. Probably the best NY Style in the area

Really good Ny slice

First time trying. Was impressed with the pie. Undercarriage was nice. Not too much flop. Great taste.

Crisp is good and a little saucy for being a thin pizza but very good

No flop, good crisp. Cheese and sauce have great flavor and melt in your mouth whe you bite into it

Very disappointed. The sauce is straight from a hunts can. The pizza is cooked really well and has no flop. These places need to stop using cheap ingredients. If this was fresh and good ingredients it would be great pizza.

Gave this place a 7.7 originally, I think they changed there sauce because it taste really cheap, could be good nys pizza but they fucked that sauce up bro