Padrino’s

This is NY Style Best Pizza, This Marg slice was good, sorry, great. Very thin slice, however don’t let this deter you from the taste. Owners were good people, they know how to advertise their pizza. If you’re in the area I’d get the marg/specialities. The pep slice didn’t look great but the taste is good. Overall worth your slice.

Buffalopizzaguy….if you’re reading this…GET F**ked, because the fellas are coming. Anyways onto the pizza. This place is now known as NY Style Best Pizza. Been hearing some rumbling about this new spot and had to go try it. The pizza shops that were in this location prior were nothing but beyond bad. But NY Style Best Pizza has brought life to this location like when Jack eichel got drafted by the Sabres. This pizza had great flavor. Spectacular crisp and you could tell the cheese and sauce is freshly made. Would for sure recommend stopping in for a slice if you’re in the area. Also the workers inside are beyond nice. Good spot with good pizza and great people.

NY Style Best Pizza*** This location changes like the weather. However I think we finally have a spot good enough to stick around. This pizza blows the past spots out of the water. Pissing on the grave of Padrino’s, Chubby’s, and West Seneca Pizza. The dark days on this spot are over! You can tell this place uses high quality ingredients especially the cheese. Unlike the prior locations which threw grease slop in a box and tried to sell it and take advantage of customers. The man working was extremely friendly and welcoming. Pizza was exceptionally good. Would’ve been better to eat it with my pals. Has been awhile since we’ve gotten to review slices together miss y’all…. buffalopizzaguy you’re a weiner, eat shit.

HOLD ON A FREAKIN’ MINUTE!! West Seneca Pizza is averaging a very low score but careful investigation shows these bad reviews were all done on the same day. Friends of Chubby’s? Who knows, who cares. I’m here to set the record straight. I did review this place when it was Chubby’s and SPOILER ALERT, it’s the same damn pizza (almost). The dough, fresh with a nice crisp in the crust. It wasn’t crispy underneath at all but not floppy and it’s obvious that if there was any crispness, it was lost during the delivery. This is why an on site pizza review is so important… The sauce is exactly how I remember. Robust, seasoned well enough to keep a neutral flavor, not sweet and not too bold (rare occurrence). The cheese, not my favorite. In fact, it kind of hurt this pie. It didn’t taste as fresh as it could. In conclusion, the pizza is a 6.8 with the foundation for an 8 pizza all day. MY 10 RATING IS TO BALANCE OUT THE OTHER REVIEWS. As an experienced reviewer, I’ve always submitted fair scores but this new place deserves better than that it shows.

Not bad, not awful could use some work though

hands down the worst slice i ever had. feels like i’m eating a slice of bread dunked in half melted plastic and anal lube. felt bad to give them a 0.0 so i gave them a 0.1. that shit was some ass. id rather go starving than eat here ever again.

The pepperoni and crust were the only medicore thing about this pizza. Absolute no sauce and tasted like someone left the garlic powder open over it. Absolutely terrible. That’s a review

I didn’t think a slice can get like this but this is rock bottom for pizza. This pizza is ranch worthy. Rats wouldn’t even order this pizza. The crust is saving it from from being a 1.4. That’s a review.

Great spicy sauce, pretty typical other than that

Pizza was amazing. Sauce is on point and crust was light and fluffy. The cheese was so good and was plenty of it. Must try pizza in the area!!

Good cheese

I would categorize this as an above average “homemade” pizza. Got a jar sauce flavor and chewy crust.