Pagliai's Pizza

The taste is superb. But I personally don’t like the way the cheese glops together. I take a bite and it all comes off leaving a sauced piece of bread.

House special thin crust was amazing! Sausage made in house with a great sauce and fresh ingredients puts this one into the 9’s!!!

My previous review here was not in house so I don’t feel as if it was a fair review. This is my hometown pizza but it is obviously an unbiased score. Overall, pretty decent pizza. Good crust and no flop. However, the toppings come sliding right off per usual. There could have been a little more sauce as well. If it weren’t for those factors, it would be in the ballpark of an 8.3

The cheese is ooey gooey delicious, homemade sausage is spot on and the deep dish crust is soft yet crusty

One of the best pizzas I’ve had in western Kentucky! Very close flavor to one of my all time favorites that is now closed so I loved it!

Double crust and deep dish. Both were good but prefer the double crust. It has more crisp. Definitely will be back!

Floppiest, messiest pizza I’ve had in my day

Great pizza, nice atmosphere. Good crust, very heavy pizza. Little flop.

Solid pizza! A heavy slice but good ingredients

One bite.