Palumbo's Italian Eatery

Beautiful slice, the sauce tastes amazing. Somehow better than most ny spots. Mad delicious.

Unique grandma pie. No flop, good crust, interesting sauce. Not your traditional pizza but overall decent.

Good selection of slice options. Fast, good price. Pretty basic pie, sweeter sauce, a little flop

The worst pizza I've ever had! Soggy, floppy, literally soaking wet with grease.

Great flop, sauce tastes sweet which I like and there’s just the right amount of crunch with the crust. Only thing I would change is the amount of cheese. Too much for me but overall a very good pie.

Literally the greasiest pizza I have ever had. It was dripping down my elbows. Everything else was good so I won’t ding them too hard.

Good drunk pizza. Not good not bad. Few more beers I’d probably house an entire pie.

Grandma pizza

This slice was lukewarm so there was zero flop by default. This pizza didn’t even deserve the ridiculous fresh parsley garnish. It wasn’t worth the $2 it cost, the energy it takes to chew it, or the calories to digest it. Huge fail.

Not Terrible. Zero flop but lots of grease. No crazy flavors. Crust snaps in half.

Sauce is phenomenal, pizza just ok. Ton of cheese.

One bite, everyone knows the rules. *meanwhile I go ahead and eat an entire slice.* So I walk to Strawberry Square to get pizza this evening to grab a pizza and as I go towards the register, the staff member walks into the back with their phone. I immediately turn around thinking "I am not risking a halfass pie, I am going to Palumbo's, because they clearly care about making a decent pizza." So I walk to Palumbos. When I get there I am immediately greeted by someone who at least acts like they care, which is all I need from a customer service perspective. The pie is great. Near perfectly cooked, enough flop to control and the cheese loss from pulling out the slice was less than I expected. The sauce reminded me of my favorite childhood pizzaria that has a hint of sweetness to it. There was also some green garnishment on there that make it appear to be a more upscale pie. Only downside is a few of the slices have significant sauce on the crust, so a little sloppy to eat, but not a big problem.

Pizza was good, but below average! Crust was thin and slightly crispy, but had offered very little structure. Sauce was heavy, flavorful, and full of spices. Cheese was overpowered, but by itself was still just average!

Crust was slightly under done and not very well baked . Nice sauce and good flop .

One bit everybody knows the rules. Good grandma slice, perfectly baked. Good sauce and dough, cheese is a bit of a low point for me. This pizza is a 7.9. that's a review.