Papa D Pizza

Light sauce garlic taste over sweet, quality cheese, crust was lacking no crunch, snapped and crumbled when folded, Make sure you check hours as they aren’t always open at the same time every day. Not a bad pie, good football pizza and the XL is quality size.

Not a bad pizza, just a little too much flop for me! Would've scored higher if the sauce had more and if the pizza was well done. Enjoy

No flop, thin, crispy crust, light sauce, good cheese, my style of pizza.

Meh dough a little old sauce not that good

New owner- new review. Solid slice, very little flop and a good flavor.

I’ve been to both Sally’s and Pepe’s in New Haven. Papa D’s is at least as good as Pepe’s. Anybody who says otherwise doesn’t know pizza.

No Flop. Great Crisp. Everyone knows the rules

The customer service was phenomenal, I really like how quick they were, very friendly. But I have to go on taste and what my coworkers rate it. It’s all about the sauce , 6.7 and 6.2

Soo Good

Alway good, one of my fancy places. Little flop, good crisp, sauce is nice, good sweetness and good zing.

Meh

Alright first off let me say this is not my style pizza. I may even be a little high with my score. Also had their plain cheese pie. Both were a little undercooked. Sauce was sweet for me and missing that “zing”. The cheese and toppings weren’t bad at all. Crust was missing taste and crunch possibly from being undercooked - that’s a review.