Papa Joe's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Pretty Good slice. The stuffed shells are better

Thin slice, no flop. Very good cheese, sauce combo. Very good pie.

Regarded as one of the best pizza places in Cape Coral, papa joes has always been a mom and pop Italian place that locals go too a lot. The pizza was New York style but a little on the heavy side. Had some flop, crisp undercarriage, not burnt at all, lacking a little more sauce or else it would be in the 8’s. Still a solid pizza I’d recommend, the vibes inside are traditional and very family welcoming.

Great NY style

Ordered carry out, opened up Immediately, disappointed by being warm, and I was there 15 mins before pickup time, flop, cheese good, sauce good, crust good. Solid 7.5

Thin, crispy, not as greasy as other pizzas nearby. Best slice I've had in the area

Good crunch, cooked perfectly, good flavor. Could use just a little more sauce.

Little greasy a little floppy buy good taste

Traditional style pepperoni, thin crust oven baked, quality cheese, fantastic staff and atmosphere.