Papa Joe's Pizza & Italian Restaurant

Well used to be papa joes was a place to cook at home pizza I think. This is a franchise pretty sure a few around. Picked up two cheese slices off a full pie no reheat. Pizza between ny and bar pie. Thicker than a bat pie. Very crunchy and crispy. Ate driving no problem. Great under carriage and cheese and sauce great. No bubbles $3.00 a slice. Lake mary has a bunch of pizza places not many good buy this is good if in area would go here. The score is tained because florida just bad but think its worth at least 7.5 we have so little to compare to in central florida. Might be a 7.6 but I am stocking with score. Very crunchy for thickness of slice.

Real quality slices. Good crisp and not a lot of grease. Great neighborhood pizza spot

Good New York style slice. Great crisp, pretty big NY flop, good crust. But, too much grease and just a fair overall flavor keeps this below a 7. Still pretty solid for Florida.

Good sauce, crust is crunchy and thin with a great made daily taste, cheese is flavorful, bit greasy but delicious

Maybe the best in Lake Mary area

Two slices, good bit of flop, little bit of grease, decent sauce. Would be a great football pizza. Solid slice.

Nice and crispy with no flop. One of the best around Lake Mary it’s worth a try.

Looks like a flaccid, unappealing pie but actually crisp. No central Florida flop. Grease about a 6. Good football/kids birthday party pizza. Owner has jokes & seems like an old Italian who knows his gravy.