The #10. My absolute favorite. No one does it like Papa’s. Perfection.
smiller32/13/21, 10:53 p.m.
Great crisp, sauce you can taste the freshness, has a tang. Up there with the new haven pizzas
dam0007bass1/19/20, 12:07 a.m.
Great pie. Fresh cheese and good tang to the sauce. Crust is a great midway point between being medium thickness and thin compared to New Haven pies.
anthony.falcon10/18/19, 9:31 p.m.
Very good sauce, cheese was good. A little bit burnt (but that’s new haven style) could be better with toppings
alexander.lamere9/27/19, 11:52 p.m.
Sharp pie, nice coal fired New Haven style. Fits the Friday night pie to the letter. Enjoy with a cold beer on the couch for under $20.
chuck.kalander6/1/19, 4:03 p.m.
Better cheese pie than Pepe’s, Modern and Bar. If this place was in New Haven it would be mentioned with the big guys. Fantastic pie, tasty sauce and cheese and a perfect crust. Best thing about Papa’s is consistency, always cooked perfectly each and every time. Take a trip to Milford, you won’t regret it.
justin_c5/23/19, 12:37 a.m.
This is really good pizza that truly is New Haven style. This is possibly the best in Milford.
o_aurelia4/14/19, 9:12 p.m.
For the reputation this place has in the local area, it was very average. There is a big difference between charred and burnt, and this pizza was the latter. Nothing special.
jabroner3/1/19, 7:43 p.m.
Overall - The roof of my mouth/tongue are destroyed BUT no regrets! One of the better pizzas in the area, no doubt. Sauce - quality sweet tomatoes which melded nicely to offset char of the dough. Dough - great flavor development, the guy knows what he is doing back there Cheese - high quality although added a little too much grease (small complaint but nbd). Impressed and will be back!!
steelrz123/1/19, 7:12 p.m.
Solid pizza. Great crust. A little too greasy. I would order this all day. One of the better Milford pies
kevin.cellini2/5/19, 7:26 p.m.
My Brother Eddie and I are faithful Loyalists to Papa’s Pizza on Naugutuck Avenue in Milford CT. The Head Pizza Maker name is Russ, he is the Maestro of Pizza. Noone can compare to The Pizza made by Russ. Papa’s is known for their Wooster Street New Haven Style Pizza, without the long lines and long waits. It is a Takeout Only Pizza Place , but does have a few Picnic Tables outside for those who would like to eat out fresh from the ovens. Just a little background on my brother and I....We are Diehard Pizza Fans and have traveled good distances to try all kinds of pizza...None can compare to Papa’s Pizza in Milford CT And just to let everyone know, Papa’s Pizza is not a local place to us... It’s a good 30 Minutes Drive with traffic to get there and another Half Hour back home to sink our teeth into this Creation from the Heavens!!! There mist be 30-40 Pizza Places if not more, thats just a count off the top of my head, and NONE can Compare!!! Hey El Presidente David!!!...please, if you can, try this place I’m your travels for i have watched each one of your reviews, and know the style pizza you like is the very same kind of baked pizza my brother and I love. As for anyone else reading this review???...Please, if you have not tried Papa’s Pizza as of yet and are a true connoisseur of True New Haven Style Pizza!!!... please give them a try! Make sure to tell Russ that the Boys from Trumbull, Kevin and Eddie, recommended going to him!!! Truly The Best!!!!
colin.spillane1/22/19, 12:51 a.m.
Hands down best pizza in Connecticut! Great sauce, cheese and perfect well done crust.
brian.cody1/6/19, 3:38 a.m.
The best pizza in Milford, CT magazine top 10 pie in the state. Definitely rivals any New Haven spot. Take out only!