Very unassuming place from the outside. Small interior and mostly just takeout. The guy who worked there was incredibly friendly and made it a really great experience. He even saw me with a child and asked if we wanted the pizza less done than normal since kids often don’t like char (I said to make it normal). The pizza was cooked very well with a small amount of flop. Excellent crust. Good flavor with minimal grease. It’s a fairly standard pie but well executed. I debated whether to go over an 8. Slightly under may be fair but the friendliness of the staff elevated it for me.
cj.ivor4/17/21, 12:44 a.m.
Great pie. Crust had solid crunch, sturdy undercarriage. Sauce was sweet, cheese a strong, good sour. Quality Milford pie in the New Haven style.
o_aurelia4/3/21, 7:17 p.m.
Had really high hopes for this pie, because papas original is one of my favorite local spots. Middle was soup city and had to hold it 12 inches above my head to get it in my mouth, that’s how bad the flop was. Speaking of flop, this experience was a flop. Crust also wasn’t good. Sauce was this pies only saving grace.
ct-nyc-pizzadude2/11/21, 4:26 p.m.
Best New Haven style pizza in town. Excellent sauce, cheese, crispy, crunchy dough and crust, little char, good undercarriage, all the specialty pies and any topping is great with this pizza
mikeperry1/18/20, 9:16 p.m.
Very good take out pie great crisp fresh. Best pie in Milford if your looking for crisp and fresh ingredients.
chuck.kalander9/21/19, 12:14 a.m.
Good pie. The cheese standouts as the winner. Definitely needs more sauce, crust was crispy enough. Not in the same league as the original Papa’s on Naugatuck Ave.
michael.lombard3/9/19, 1:37 a.m.
Great New Haven Apizza. Off the beaten path, worth the stop. Great staff. Will return
ryan.tuohey12/28/18, 5:26 p.m.
Perfect slice in Milford. Flavor is unbeatable aaaaaand fully get that burnt taste on the bottom. Will never go wrong with this slice
nolan.rourke8/31/18, 10:28 p.m.
Crispy crust, perfect amount of flop, toppings never disappoint. Very expensive but worth every penny