18 views•1 like
Very good, loved the cheese, crust is good but a bit bland, sauce has a nice pop to it with a little bite. Solid tomatoe pie. 8.3
anewyorkerinthelou12/30/22, 6:10 p.m.
The mustard pie flavor is really interesting, and my family preferred it over the tomato pie, but both were excellent. Mustard pie: 8.8 Tomato pie: 8.5
rich.dott12/27/22, 10:20 p.m.
Worth a 50 min drive but not an hour drive. Pizza was great; not excellent.
kim.tomlinson12/27/22, 10:17 p.m.
Tomatoes are super fresh and prevalent in this pizza. Great crunch on the crust too!
matt.soffer12/27/22, 4:49 p.m.
Premier crisp, great undercarriage, solid cheese to sauce ratio. Zero flop. Sauce didn’t quite have the zip to push the score higher
brooklyn.joe.in.jersey12/22/22, 3:56 a.m.
Top shelf crust and undercarriage. Quality ingredients. Unique taste, especially the mustard pie. Not far off from a 9.1.
andres.ferradans12/2/22, 7:46 p.m.
Alright alright alright,this is what Im talking about! Divine crust!! Sauce on the tangy side dont love it but I can see people liking it, it is just my preference, cheese ratio perfect
z.worthington11/13/22, 7:24 p.m.
110 years this place has been slinging Trenton style Tomato Pie. Dough was super thin and crispy from first bite to the last. Ratios of dough sauce and chese was right on the money, and the sauce is just ripe tomatoes, fresh and vibrant red with a slight natural sweetness. Very tasty pizza.
everettlogan10/14/22, 1:32 a.m.
While I think the original, now long gone, DeLorenzo Tomato Pies was the best Trenton style tomato pie ever, Papa’s is now the best existing one. Their sauce is the best sauce is simply amazing, a perfect 10 on the sauce. The cheese blends with it perfectly and is just the right amount. The only thing holding Papa’s back is their crust is just the tiniest bit bland. It’s cooked perfectly and the texture is fantastic. It could just use a tad more flavor. But, hands down one of the best pies of all time.
patrick.brown129/25/22, 8:50 p.m.
Sweet sauce and every bite crispy. Just a pleasure. And the service was terrific, good people pleasant to deal with.
sixeightharry9/24/22, 11:43 p.m.
Excellent Pie. Zero flop is an understatement. One of the crispiest slices I ever had. Delicious sauce. Amazing crust, crispy but not burnt. Worth the trip.
sean.newsome19/10/22, 9:55 p.m.
Tomatoes take center stage (and they are good). Crispy with a bit of flop. Cheese is also good.
meatybonez9/4/22, 11:40 p.m.
Outstanding tomato style pie…perfect sauce, & crisp. A must travel to place. Try the mustard pie also…you won’t be disappointed
megan.snyder18/28/22, 11:45 p.m.
beautiful. floppiness was a 3/10, undercarriage was crispy and thin, cheese was perfect and the sauce was very flavorful. Not as good once it’s cooled down, gotta eat it fresh and hot.
billysalts8/16/22, 4:44 p.m.
Mustard pizza with homemade sausage and cherry peppers. Nice crust!