Papa's Tomato Pies

Amazing! My boyfriend and I got the plain and half pepperoni half sausage. So flavorful and the crust was very tasty. Highly recommend. Worth the 45 minute trip for sure

No flop with great crunch. Sauce is so good, my Italian grandmother left her grave and slapped me for loving it so much. If you like thin crust, you’ll love it. If you don’t, you’re obviously a communist.

Very good pie. Nice crunch to the thin crust. Tangy and mildly sweet sauce. Definitely worth the 25 minute drive for me.

Trenton area is known for the tomato pie (cheese on the bottom tomato on top) It was very good, nice flavor and great crisp. This pizzeria is the oldest in the country according to the owner. That’s a review

Very good pie. Different style. Side note cannolis were pretty good from here too.

Yoooo I fell in love!!! Creamy cheese's delicious sauce with the perfect under carriage!!! Reminds me of Joe and Pat's just not quite as good. Side Review: chicken parm was that of ball park/flea market food very turned off and disappointed

A traditional thin pizza, very crispy.

Fantastic. Destroyed it. Sign of a good pie.

So great. Unlike any other pizza. Tomato pie that pleases me endlessly. That’s the review.

Thin, crispy & not too greasy

It’s a solid tomato pie, one of the best I’ve had

Crisp is unreal. Tomato really pops.

Solid muck. Tomato sweet and delicious. Crust was a little blander but this is an elite tomato pie. Ate 6 slices before I even knew what was going on.