Papa's Tomato Pies

Very good sauce, a little on the sweet side. Thin crust. Wish the cheese had a little more flavor.

Fantastic crunch, good tang on the sauce

The sauce and cheese are very complimentary. The bread has a great crisp. Overall, one of my new go to spots!

Another legendary NJ place with a great pie cooked perfectly. Awesome atmosphere and they serve RC Cola!!!

An original Trenton Tomato pie done right. I would like a little more sauce but I’m just being nit picky at this point. Quality stuff

Ordered by the pie. This was a very difficult review. There’s a lot right here. The crust is crisp, has good chew. But it’s also a tad dry. Additional water in the dough may help. The sauce is concentrated, but a bit one dimensional. They use the right amount of cheese, but again, it seemed to lack flavor. Overall I felt it needed a pinch of salt, but was clearly a well made pie.

VERY good pizza!! Loved it. Everything is good, sauce, cheese, it’s thin like I like it… they put the cheese on first.. so there’s these saucy spots.. it’s different. Overall taste is great. And the place has the old school vibe, which I love. VERY important to know: it’s BYOB!! 😱 If I knew this, I would have had an even better time, Ay Oh!! I repeat: they do not have alcohol! Bring your own!! You’re WELCOME!! 😉😉

The sauce is special. Very tangy.

Top 3 in NJ. Zero flop, perfect char, nice crisp, tangy but not overbearing.

Not usually a big fan of tomato pies but this is an exception. The sauce is not overpowering at all, good under carriage, nice crisp and good flavor. The crust at the end is on the dry side and is what holds back an 8.3 or 8.4.

Real deal pizza. Superb char on the bottom. Light on sauce and cheese so you can easily eat a pie to yourself.

No flop, perfect crisp. All around good pizza

One of the best pizzas ever flavorful, great crisp.

This has the perfect tangy sauce & perfect crust, not better than Delorenzo’s around the corner but still top tier

Pie is on point every time. Perfect crunch, no flop . Ideal cheese to sauce ratio. Every bite a pleasure.

Amazing crunch! Every single bite was crunchy. Great sauce to cheese ratio, barely any grease. Sauce was a little sweet but all around good flavor.

This is one of the best pizza’s i have ever had, its better than most of the great New York places. Great sauce, cheese, crust, and flavors

The crust and sauce were PHENOMENAL! Definitely worth coming here

Excellent cheese to sauce ratio. Sauce had tang and was very good. Great crunch. If it wasn’t a little floppy the score would’ve been higher. Overall very good and definitely worth your time.

Great taste, light and crispy.

Try the mustard pie! Great slice

This pizza place is absolute garbage. While the pizza has a decent under carriage and ok crisp, the cheese is greasy and bland, just like the old lady at the front. The sauce was gross and had no flavor. Dave was wrong with this one. Pick up your game with you’re unsophisticated palate. Maddie, you’re cool. Your too good for that place. They don’t deserve you.

Thin, crispy pie. Low grease levels with sweet sauce. Cheese a little lacking but quality slice all the way around. Well suited for lower-middle socio-economic class.

Bomb crunch sauce is fuego grease level on point. Ate entire pie. Would suggest.