Been having this pizza since the day I was born. Live very close to this area. So i have to say it’s very good pizza. The cheese is amazing, the sauce is awesome. Pizza Cove will always be in my heart. I’ve been eating this since I was a kid. I still eat it to this day!
steve.hudsons9/9/20, 5:21 p.m.
Sauce tasted like it was straight out of a can. Crust very plain and “dry”
thebigc8/19/19, 4:09 p.m.
Good crust . Nice amount of cheese. Sauce needs little more bite and more sauce on pie. Friendly service. Great 4.99 lunch special during the week. 2 slices and 16 oz soda Mon to Fri. Enjoy !!
trump-of-pizza8/1/19, 6:01 p.m.
Pappalardo’s, big time flop, crust and pizza is very doughy, which is no bueno, sauce is good, no grease, I had this pizza awhile ago and it used to be a lot better, not sure what happened..The Regular is a 5.9, The Buffalo is 5.8
zachary.worthington7/13/19, 1:49 a.m.
Holy fuck is this good. How is this place rated so low. The crust has some serious crisp, the sauce has a sweet tomato flavor and the cheese is bangin. This is my 36th review, i’m a seasoned vet! If you get the chance, give it a try.
dan.opallo6/12/19, 11:43 p.m.
This is a NEIGHBORHOOD. PIZZERIA. Everyone is treated like family. Also, the cheese and sauce are tastier than almost any place else you’ll find. Definitely worth a stop in. Say hey to Joey!!
steven.d12/8/18, 6:13 p.m.
A Massapequa legend, sauce has nice flavor and very cheesy, crust thicker than normal Long Island pizza but something is missing. The missing ingredient is a belly full of alcohol this is classic late night fair that doesn’t seem that great in the middle of the afternoon.
pizza24seven10/31/18, 3:36 a.m.
Found this after a best of Long Island review. The slice was very good. Not as good as I had expected considering the “fame” they had been given. Still it was definitely worth the money and is worth trying if you’re a pizza fan and nearby. Strange name though.
pj.g9/23/18, 12:08 a.m.
Pizza has right amount of flop. The sauce has a slight tang, but it works. I grew up eating this pizza so maybe it’s a taste that I’m looking for. A bit doughy, but the crust is good and crunchy. The regular slice beat the meatball slice.
timpy638/30/18, 1:51 a.m.
Def football style pizza. Got that pizza flop. Slice was greasy. Good crust.